At your budget, looking for a classic tube sound, and needing at least midrange power -- I think restored vintage or vintage inspired amps are the way to go.
I started out in tube amps with restored Heathkit and Eico amps. They sound wonderful. If you love that wonderful Koetsu sound (especially paired with 12AX7 phono and CineMag 1254 as you've done), this is your kind of sound.
From there I moved on to Rogue Audio because I wanted more power. This is a common recommendation in your price point (Cronus, Atlas, Stereo 100). They're excellent but will NOT give a classic tube sound, particular in the midband. They excel in bass and dynamics, and respond well to tube rolling -- so you can dial up the sweetness, to a point. It still won't sound like classic tubes.
And from there now I have modern VAC amps. Very expensive. Amazing blend of classic tube sound and modern high performance hifi. But very expensive. You might find some of their much older models for $3K used, and they can be very good. VAC still services everything they've ever made.
I think the Dynaco recommendation by @jasonbourne52 is a very good one. Someone was making modernized amps / kits from these designs (Bob Latino?), but I'm not sure if they're still around.