2. analog
  3. 126890-37711

Rega RP6 vs Pro Ject 1Xpession Carbon - is there $500 difference

OK looking for some help from someone who hopefully has first hand experience with both these tables....I am getting ready to buy a second table, my choices are the Rega RP6 vs Pro Ject 1Xpession Carbon , both come with speedbox and the Rega is $500 more , is it worth it?

I already know its a better table......I am a chronic researcher before I buy anything and I really cant find a head to head comparison......leave the cartridge out of the comparison, I have several of my own.

Both have a really good price on them right now from separate places so theres no asking the salesman, I have no store locally that has either table in to listen to, and I am afraid the sale is going to go off soon so I have to decide asap.

again , $500 difference?! maybe? No? Yes?.....I have smoke coming out of my ears reading about both, and others, and trying to decide!

The Rega is a little above what I was shooting to spend on a second table (my other is a modified Thorens TD 160 ) but I am willing to go that route if its worth the $500

any help would be greatly appreciated !


bairdz
11 responses Add your response
bairdz OP
3 posts
 
I guess I should add I understand how hard this is without a true a/b test with the same cartridge mounted, I am more looking for , is the difference worth it based on build quality, tonearms, speedboxs (I am not sure if the Rega speedbox is better than the Pro-Jects S model speedbox?) , etc.

The Pro Ject does come with a Sumiko cartridge but I am not a fan, that will go to my grandsons table as a spare, so actually a little more than $500 difference
orpheus10
8,668 posts
 
get the rega.
wolf_garcia
6,693 posts
 
I think Regas are brilliant designs and I get that…the RP6 is way cool, HOWEVER…and I’ve mentioned this before…no VTA is a deal killer…shims? Nope…that seems like a both a "bandaid" approach and lacks the adjustment accuracy I think is necessary to get those micro adjustments right. I get that with an installed Rega cart these things work fine (I’ve heard them…they work), but when my local Rega dealer said he could show me how to get the lid to close on a Rega using my current fave cart, I thought, "huh?" I know it’s heresy to Rega’s design philosophy, but I bet if they designed VTA adjustment into those tables (like pretty much every other damn table designer on Earth) they’d sell more of ’em…one to me for sure. Also, I really like the looks of the new Pro-Ject "The Classic"…the arm looks like a Rega! Might have to get me one of those, and they're not too pricey.
gshepardbuster's avatar
gshepardbuster
620 posts
 
The best way to avoid "flipping your lid" with a Rega on shims is to use a dropped counterweight, lid will then close as it should.  
lenmc2964's avatar
lenmc2964
240 posts
 
Get the Rega have one and love it. If needed the  Acoustic Signature Spacer Set for Rega work fine. 
sunnyjim
927 posts
 

The anti-skating on most Rega tables is junk and not accurate.  Check out AG, there is lightly used Project  2Xperience classic which is better than 1Xpereince. It has a Sumiko BP-2 MC with low hours,  and the seller is offering a ton of record accessories with the table for $999, or best offer. The TT looks in mint condition. . 

Good Luck!

 

boofer
86 posts
 
For my 2 cents worth, I've had the Rega P3, P5, RP6, and RP8, the latter 3 with TTPSU's. I've also had the Project Expression III, with the fishline antiskate.  Those  all have been sold and I currently have a Technics SL 1300 and restored [byV.N.] Thorens TD 150 and 160Super. These vintage TTs I vastly prefer to the Projects and Regas..The 2 Thorens have  Jelco 750D tonearms.By the way, Sunnyjim, I'm curious as to which TT you finally settled on, if you don't mind sharing this info.
sbrownnw
692 posts
 
I think so. I had 2 pro-ject tables, original xpression and xpeession III. MY current RP6 blows both away. See my system details what I use with it. It boogies and does blues and classical well.
bairdz OP
3 posts
 
all great comments, but is there $500 difference?
thats still what I am wondering......and thanks SUNNYJIM , I gave that table another look and asked the seller a couple questions but have yet to get an answer.....plus its a Xperience and I am looking at a Xpression, wondering whats higher on the food chain there??
boofer
86 posts
 
The  2 Xperience is quite a bit higher on the food chain. As I recall, around$1500 whereas the Xpression is less than $1000. Check Needle Doctor under turntables for prices on a slew of turntables.
sunnyjim
927 posts
 

Bairdz....  Boofer is correct about the higher level of the 2Xperience and the pricing.

Not to highjack your thread I just want to mention to Boofer that I have not made a decision on the turntable, however, there is a Rega RP6 with their cartridge and speed controller on AG for sale  I am tempted but I owned a Rega P3-24 about 5 years ago, and wanted to try something. different.  I looked at the SOTA turntables The Moonbeam is attractive looking in its natural oak wood chassis, but the arm is an OEM  R202 probably made by Rega   Overall. despite good reviews, especially about speed stability and construction, it looks flimsy, and you get no dustcover The next model is the Comet IV which is supposedly better but has few accessories or pre-packed cartridge and costs $1600  Neither table, despite SOTA's reputation, seems a very good value to me, especially compared to the Rega RP-6 with the Exact II spike. 

Thanks, Bairdz .for the use of the space  Good Luck

Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
Lenco Reference MKI
80x80
Thorens TD 124
80x80
Garrard 401