Fleschler, some additional input relating to the hypothesis I provided earlier that in some cases might explain sonic differences between supposedly identical CDs.
An Audiogon member whose screen-name is Kirkus is, in addition to being one of our most technically brilliant contributors, highly experienced in analyzing and measuring the internal circuits of CD players, transports, and DACs. An excerpt of a post he provided on 7-20-2011 in this thread:
Regards,
-- Al
An Audiogon member whose screen-name is Kirkus is, in addition to being one of our most technically brilliant contributors, highly experienced in analyzing and measuring the internal circuits of CD players, transports, and DACs. An excerpt of a post he provided on 7-20-2011 in this thread:
Two big conceptual errors I see very commonly are the assumption that any intrinsic jitter related to retrieval of information off of a CD actually occurs through the forward signal/data path, and that any sonic artifact associated with parts upstream of the DAC must be classifiable as jitter.Such effects figure to be dependent on the physical characteristics of the particular pressing, the condition of the disc, and the design of the particular playback hardware. And to have little if any predictability.
In reality, CD players, transports, and DACs are a menagerie of true mixed-signal design problems, and there are a lot of different noise sources living in close proximity with susceptible circuit nodes. One oft-overlooked source is crosstalk from the disc servomechanism into other parts of the machine . . . analog circuitry, S/PDIF transmitters, PLL clock, etc., which can be dependent on the condition of the disc.
... One would be surprised at some of the nasty things that sometimes come up out of the noise floor when the focus and tracking servos suddenly have to work really hard to read the disc.
Regards,
-- Al