Top ten tube preamps


What are your top 10 tube line stage preamps of all time?
samuellaudio
Saying the ARC Ref3 is the worst tube preamp you ever heard is a remarkable statement. I would consider myself fortunate if it were the worst I ever heard.
Post removed 
That Lamm LL2 Deluxe was a real sleeper, and I never knew why, maybe too "cheap" for folks to believe it could be as good as it is - I wish I had not sold that one. "Low prices" might be a "problem" for linestages like the Lightspeed Attenuator from Australia which will give any of the tube linestages mentioned in this thread a run for their money in the right system, and at $450, I mean that literally.
BAT Rex currently occupies the coveted position in my system...I'd like to audition Atma-Sphere, VAC, and Win Analog :-)

Best regards,
Sam
I replaced my Ref3 with the Lamm LL1 Signature dual mono preamp. Nothing more needs to be done.IMO this is the last word in preamps
I felt that way when I got my NAD 3020 - if only there were a last word in gear. I guess when it sounds just like live music, but I don't see that happening any time soon.
Post removed 
Of course I am a tube pre fan, having owned ARC, CAT, Lamm, and currently Atma-sphere and Joule preamps, and all of you are fans too, but I would suggest that just on a lark, and for only $450 you try a Lightspeed Attenuator if you have a tube amp (100kohm input impedance). It is limited to one rca input and output, but compare it with your megabuck preamps and see what you think. I have had some dissapointmet with variour passives (resistor, TVCs and AVCs) but this humble little preamp is the best I have heard in my system. Even if you stick with your tube preamps, I'm not getting rid of mine, it makes for an interesting backup, at the very least, and perhaps you might find that you like it better than anything you throw up against it. Some thought to system matching is needed (as using SETs would be) but if you can get used to the idea of using a $450 preamp in your $50,000 setups, you might be surprised. My recommedation now for SOTA sound at a bargain prices is a Music Reference RM10 amp matched with the Lightspeed. With the money of the gear being discussed here, it is worth a try IMHO.
Below is my ranking. I owned them all except for the Cortese, which spent an afternoon in my system compliments of a friend.

1. SMc VRE-1
2. First Sound Deluxe Mk II
3. SupraTek Cortese
4. Joule La-150 Mk I
5. Blue Circle BC-3
6. McIntosh C-15

I never thought I would end up with a solid state preamp, but after 18 months I have not felt the slightest itch to change or try something different.
Hope to get a chance to hear that VRE-1 at RMAF - the reviews and owner comments have been bery positiive.
I don't understand why the McCormack preamp went from 7500 to 15k. can someone clue us in?

Thanks,

KeithR
Post removed 
too bad---i don't think many folks are going to read reviews on a piece at 7500 then pony up double for it. of course i could be wrong.
Post removed 
I have owned and listened to many a preamp over the past 5-7 years and the Tube Research Labs (TRL) Dude tube preamp ranks #1 by a very wide margin. This is based on my ears and gear over the years. It can be purchased for $3800 brand new and has to be the best value in all of high end audio. At least one of them :-)

Here are the others I have owned. The best of this group was the CJ LS16 V2, Thor TA1000 and Audio Horizons 2.1 fully loaded with all the possible upgrades. As you can tell I like tube preamps!

Audio Horizons TP2.1 fully loaded
Joule LA100 MKIII
Conrad Johnson LS16 V2
Thor 1000 MK2
Tom Evans Vibe
Supratek Cortese
Supratek Syrah
Audio Note m5
Wavac PR-X1
Rowland Concerto
Rowland Capri
Cary SLP98
Aesthetix Calypso
Tube Distinctions SoulMate
Placette passive
Wright Sound WLA 12A
Aloia 11.01
Belles 21A
Rogue 99

Buy the Dude for the sound as the fit and finish are good or OK, but not like a CJ etc... With the Dude it's all about the sound. It completely changed my audio experience by delivering music in a way that is so effortless, dynamic and at ease. I had thought this experience was simply not possible with electronics.

Never feel the need to try another.
While the CJ-PV12 would not rate in the top ten, it is the best Jazz Pre I have ever heard. When you drop some NOS RCA tubes in it, the horns take on a golden glow.
I likewise own a Giscours and it is a keeper for life. It is a musical instrument. Uncanny.
My favorite is the one I built for myself. It sounds EXACTLY the way I like preamps to sound...go figure.

If you want something done right...

And in all honesty, it beats the pants off my Supratek.
Purity Audio will soon end up on this list as people compare it with the ones already mentioned. The design and components used are of the highest calibre.
Atma,

It's a linestage. I already have a phono stage that is good down to .1mV cartridges, so I'm covered there.

Swampwalker,

I think it sounds great, probably because I made it to sound the way I like my music to sound. Next project is a 200+wpc SET to go along with it; I'm accumulating the parts now, with the transformers being the most challenging, but I've got a good line on those now. The LTspice simulations look great, at 218wpc with zero negative feedback.
The main character in the 200W SET saga:

The 833C

BTW, it's also a DHT, just a multi-kilovolt B+ version.
Ait- Ah, the famed 833C. WAVAC fans will be jealous ;-) Do you do the casework yourself? I'm thinking the amp will be quite breathtaking! And I am totally in awe of ee types who understand the technical stuff.
Swampwalker,

I do some of the casework, farm some of it out when it's past the level of my drill press and Greenlee punches. Chrome work is done by a local plating shop that usually does bumpers and exhaust pipes; they were amused when I told them what the plates from my preamp were for.

The 833 will be a true challenge, and I expect it to take the better part of this year to complete. When you're talking thousands of volts the parts are harder to find and a lot more expensive, and every connection must be triple-checked before the ultra high voltage gets anywhere near it. I'm still working out the safety systems to ensure no electrocutions or fires result.

That said, it should be fun!
Samuellaudio- sorry for hijacking your thread.
Ait-
I'm still working out the safety systems to ensure no electrocutions or fires result.
Ah, what's the fun in that? There's a reason they call it "the bleeding edge" ;-)
Without a doubt ,wyetech ruby STD in a sound class all by itself , speaking from a guy that has an MBL preamp
I don't know about top ten, but, I have heard good sound from systems using the following:

Emotive Audio Epifania (I own one of these)

Aldo preamp (custom built preamp from a Western Electric rebuilder in Italy-transform inputs and outputs. I also own one of these)

Veloce (I heard a nice system at a show using this preamp)

Audionote (uk) M-10 linestage and phono preamp (you need an extra room to house these monsters with their multiple power supplies)

Audionote (Kondo) M-10 linestage (I auditioned Stax Omega II headphones on a system with this linestage and bought the phones. They have NEVER sounded as good as when played through the Kondo).
Add to the list the deHavilland UltraVerve III with the remote and a good NOS 6SN7. I am using one to drive a McCormack DNA 0.5 Deluxe and things sound glorious.