2. speakers
  3. 1143328050

Vandersteen 5A or Eggleston Works Andra II

I will be upgrading my speakers in the near future and I have been waiting to one day upgrade to the Vandersteen 5A. I have read some good things about the Eggleston Works Andra II and I have included it on my list.

I have listened to the vandersteen 5A as well as the Quattro and will listen some more. I hope to be able to finally listen to the Andra sometime in the next 2 to 3 months when I travel to a place with a dealer for those.

I listen mostly to jazz.. world music, reggae, and everything in between that moves me.. sweet music i say.

I am interested in a speaker that is full range and flat all the way down to 20 Hz!

I usually buy for long term keeps so whatever I decide on will be staying for a long long time.

Room size is T shaped --12 x 32 long and a 9x14 short and carpeted. Whatever I decide on will move with me if I ever move, then it will be to a more dedicated room in the future I hope.

Current gear:

McCormack DNA 500
Modwright Instruments SWL 9.0SE LineStage
Integra DPS 10.5 Universal used as a Transport
Benchmark DAC1
VPI SuperScoutmaster with Signature arm and Shelter 901 MC
Mirage Frx-9
Velodyne HGS 15 II

Thank you for your suggestions and keep your other possible recommendations coming as well.
ije
vladimir
346 posts
 
I have a comment and a question for those who have heard both speakers. Years ago I listened to the original Vandersteen 5s and liked them very much; however, both by itself and when compared to the original Eggleston Andra, with which I was very familiar, the soundstage height of the Vandersteen was low, not much higher than the top of the speaker; by contrast, the Andra's height was tall and natural. Is this still the case with the newer versions?
mikej
172 posts
 
HI Vladimir, the image height is adjustable using washers and the footer cones. My 5As image higher than that. It's very natural. The manual gives directions on this and is very accurate.
dolfan
109 posts
 
I think the fact you are posting this question AFTER listening to the Vandies says something. Go listen to your buddies Andra's. If when you turn on your system at home you cannot forget what you heard at your friends the decision is made. IMHO. Good Luck!
More to discover