Vintage Mac vs. Modern Amps?


I am seriously thinking of selling my vintage McIntosh MC2200 amp and buying some Schiit, Crown, or a used Hegel or PS Audio. This Mac amp has been with me for 15 years and I thought I would never get rid of it, but I’m tired of of taking this amp to the shop every 5-6 years and waiting around for weeks or months to get it back.

I would still be keeping my Mac C27 Pre-Amp, so there would still be some Mac “sauce” in my system. What would I be losing/gaining in sound quality by going to, for example, a Shciit Vidar or a Crown? Is Mac as special as the Mac choir preaches?


128x128paul70
McIntosh SS 'sauce' is to do nothing to the signal, that was my experience.

I used a McIntosh SS Pair for years. Amp: MC2250; preamp: C28.  

Decided to go back to tubes, sold both on eBay,

AMP

I chose a used Cayin Tube amp, A88T, 45 wpc, plenty for my efficient horn speakers. Just got lucky, they are a terrific combination. Designed in Germany, to sound like McIntosh Tube Amp, built in China. Terrific quality, awesome sound.

This convinced me about the Cayin

http://www.6moons.com/audioreviews/cayin/a88t.html

If you consider tubes, perhaps look for external bias meters and external adjusters.

PREAMP

I question your retaining the SS C27. To me, if I kept my C28, that would be keeping 'do nothing'. I am very glad I went back to tubes, 

I sold my SS C28 and bought a very vintage McIntosh mx110z Tube Tuner/Preamp. Love it, and it's phono is the best I ever had. I was not fond of the SS C28's phono. I use a SUT so I can continue using mx110z's phono. It has 2 phono inputs, and trim controls to match different cartridge signal strengths, and a 3rd input with trim control. Your C27 probably has that also.

The mx110z tuner is awesome, capability and sound quality. I only listen to one station: Jazz, 88.3 in NJ, but it pulls in plenty. Again, best sounding FM I ever had. I'm 72, I've had a few. They say it needs a good signal, I have a large dedicated FM antenna in the attic right above.

This convinced me about the mx110z

https://positive-feedback.com/Issue77/vintage_mcintosh_experience.htm
................................

OR:  Keep your McIntosh SS Amp, change only your preamp.

This Vintage Luxman Tube Preamp tempts me greatly even though I don't need it

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Luxman-CL35-MKIII-Tube-Preamp/303871182981

.............................
the mc2200 dates back to 1976

there are many good sounding modern solid state amps to consider... you did not mention the balance of your system and your musical tastes

an integrated amp might be the easiest and most effective answer to excellent sound... ayre, hegel, pass and luxman are all solid state brands with a refined sound, without the typical flaws of poorly executed solid state amplification