2. analog
  3. 1209499585

Vinyl vs. digital: what am I doing wrong?

I'd like to ask you all for help with my TT setup. I think I've amassed what should be a nice sounding TT setup. However, I don't think that vinyl sounds as good as my CD (e.g., comparing the same album on vinyl vs CD).

What am I doing wrong?

Here's my TT setup:
- Basis 1400 with clamp
- Upgraded power supply
- Rega RB300 tonearm with Incongnito wiring
- Shelter 501MK2
- VPI 16.5 cleaner with AudioIntelligent cleaning products
- Zerodust stylus cleaner
- TT set up by Brooks Berdan

CD player:
- Metronome CD2V Signature

Rest of system:
- Martin Logan SL3
- Cary 805 amp
- Music Reference Amp
- Supratek Chenin preamp with built in MC phono stage

Thanks in advance for your help.

Alvin
alvinlin
Ag insider logo xs@2x
islandmandan
1,260 posts
 
Hello, I have had similar observations concerning cd vs vinyl. My digital front end always sounds good, whereas it takes a very good lp in good condition to better the cd. As was mentioned earlier in the thread, you may have loading not set right. Experimenting and learning, (not necessarily in that order), are what it takes to get vinyl sounding its best. One of the better qualities of vinyl is the degree of involvement necessary for quality listening. Just have fun with it, and settle in for the long haul, it can be a good ride.

Enjoy,

Dan
timrhu
2,779 posts
 
What are you doing wrong? Why is it wrong to prefer cd over vinyl? When done right each have their sonic merits.
A couple of years ago, after careful consideration, I sold most of my lp collection as I realized I preferred cd to vinyl. Spinning lps and all that goes with it held no real attraction for me. The decision was the right one as far as I'm concerned.
dcstep
1,518 posts
 
How good are you LP pressings? Do you have mostly used stuff, or do you have some new 180/200 gram 45 rpm vinyl? There are lots of bad pressings and poorly cared for vinyl out there. If you haven't tried them yet, get one or two really great LP reissues.

Dave
bugman03
44 posts
 
You should talk to Brooks or Brian Berdan about your setup. I am sure they can help you find the problem. I think that any properly setup TT will sound better than any digital rigs out there.
plato
1,543 posts
 
Get rid of your Shelter and buy a Benz... That's what it took to get my vinyl rig competitive with my digital.

The Shelter was always too bright in my system no matter what I did -- and my Benz cartridges seem to have a more proportionate and natural midrange. The cartridge was the last think I changed out... and the thing that made all the difference.
More to discover