Thanks to each of you who've expressed your concern. It's certainly helped my angst!
As Montepilot says, the good news is that its only money: no one was hurt, the cartridge can be replaced. (And thanks for sharing your story, Montepilot.) The better news is that a replacement cartridge is on it's way.
Regarding CD, I actually do have a CD player: a 15+ year old Rotel RCD 855. Completely inoffensive and far outclassed by current technology. The CD collection here is for sure the more limiting factor: 4,000 LPs, but at best only 50 CDs.
As to the Klimo harpsichord LP (Klimo Open Window OW001), I find it very enjoyable: an interesting selection of music, very well played by the inimitable Alfred Gross on three different harpsichords (each pretty different in character than the other), and very naturally recorded. This is certainly one of the better harpsichord records in my collection.
Another solo harpsichord LP I think is well recorded and listenable (and that is still available from Acoustic Sounds and perhaps others) is the Reference Recordings LP of Ramaeu performed by Albert Fuller (RR 27). Unlike the Klimo, this is a very close-up recording, which has its pluses and minuses. But it well captures the tonality of this instrument.
.