2. analog
  3. 1108710967

Which turntable should I keep?

After inheriting much of my Dad's classical and jazz lp collection, I've decided to rekindle my interest in vinyl. So I've pulled my old Thorens TD 145 out of storage (Stanton 681EEE) and found the box with the $10 garage sale Denon DP-51F that I bought just as it was about to find its way to the landfill. I haven't kept up with turntable and cartridge developments for the last 20 years, so I'm not sure which of these to use, or if I should buy new? The Stanton has about 7 years of moderate use on it, so I don't know if I need to replace the stylus. I've googled both of the turntables, and haven't learned much except that it seems that I should have ponied up for the TD 160 way back when. Haven't seen much on that Denon model, so I don't know if it is low or mid range equipment. I know that I've been pretty gentle with the Thorens, but don't know anything about how the Denon was treated. Its cartridge is a tan Grado with the marking GF 1? on its front. Any suggestions on what I should do? Modifications, upgrades, new purchase? Which cartridge is the keeper? Or should I buy new?
craig76
twl
3,251 posts
 
For the paltry money you have in these turntables, keep them both.

They are both good tables, but the Thorens may prove the better of the two. But the Denon is one of the better direct drive tables from that era, and is a good performer in its own right.

Replace the cartridges, and play them both to see what you like best.
johnnantais
621 posts
 
What they said, and the TD145 is simply a semi-automatic version of the TD160, so basically you already have a TD160, with some convenience thrown in. I recently set up a Stanton 681EEE for a friend and was very impressed. So much so I ordered one for me!
musicslug
430 posts
 
you might want to change cartridges before playing your lps - it the cartridge is worn and/or the tracking force is too hight you could damage the lps
c123666
871 posts
 
Try this site for Thorens information and upgrades:
http://www.theanalogdept.com/thorens_dept_.htm

The 145 would make the basis of a much better turntable. Build a better plinth, add a better tonearm and cartridge, and you are off to the races.

The Denon I would sell. It is a complex little thing with its servo arm. When (not if; it will fail eventually) it fails you will find parts very difficult to acquire. I owned a DP47F for sometime; liked it but sold it as I did not wait for it to get so old I could not recover my money.
A basic belt drive turntable is about the most reliable device known to man (and woman).
upstateaudio's avatar
upstateaudio
249 posts
 
I agree with C123666. I had a DP45F, it could not be repaired due to lack of parts. I then purchased a DP51 from the repair shop. It died within 2 weeks. The shop gave me my money back. The parts for the servo arm are hard to come by.
More to discover