I hate to judge before all the facts are in but we have here is actually nothing more than the old uber skeptics' warhorse logical fallacy, the A Priori Argument. It’s one of the favored illogical arguments for a host of audio related things but especially cables, fuses, wire directionality and controversial tweaks.
The A Priori Argument (Also, Rationalization; Proof Texting.): A corrupt argument from logos, starting with a given, pre-set belief, dogma, doctrine, scripture verse, "fact" or conclusion and then searching for any reasonable or reasonable-sounding argument to rationalize, defend or justify it. Certain ideologues and religious fundamentalists are proud to use this fallacy as their primary method of "reasoning" and some are even honest enough to say so. The opposite of this fallacy is the Taboo. See also "Two Truths."