I had Apogee Duetta IIs for years, loved the planar/ribbon sound. I had to put them in storage for a while, and one got damaged while moving them back. Long story short, I had a couple of DIY 2.5 way speakers based on Usher drivers I built that I used in the interim. While they sound good, they didn't match the Apogees. Did some speaker evaluations and wound up with Maggie 1.7i, being the closest within budget at the time.
Had a PS Audio 4.5 preamp, blew a channel shortly after hooking it up. My old DB Systems preamp had a bad cap, and I wasn't sure at the time whether I wanted it fixed. So I got an Emotiva XSP-1 Gen 2 preamp as a dealer demo. I figured it was something half decent until I could make a decision on a permanent preamp, and at the price, I could probably get out of it even. It served it's purpose.
A little while after this my Bryston 3B amp blew a channel. Sold it off and bought a PS Audio S300 as an interim amp. Good reviews and they offered to take the non working PS audio preamp on a trade with a generous trade in value.
Somewhere in there, I decided to get a dedicated phono preamp. Thanks to many good reviews and advice gotten here on AG, I picked up a Herron VSPH-2A after talking to Keith. It was more than I wanted to spend at the time, but any misgivings went away when I hooked it up and started listening. Best move I could have made anywhere near the price point, I'm totally convinced of that.
Fast forward to a couple weeks ago, as a lark I put in a bid on a BAT VK-30SE preamp that I thought didn't have a chance of winning. But it did :-). Turns out it was just serviced (same month as the auction) by BAT and came with a brand new factory set of tubes to boot.
A side effect of the new preamp was that I appreciate how good the PS Audio S300 is. I still want to eventually replace it, but I'm not in a rush at this point. It's kept up really nicely with every change I've made in the system, and drives the maggies with authority at any volume level I would even consider for short periods, and does a great job on all types of music. Pretty amazing for a real budget amp.
So, basically, some research, some educated guesses, a lot of listening, and some total luckouts. Good luck with your journey.