Seems appropriate to ask opinions on an audio mag here.
I prefer Stereophile, for the measurements and the detailed set-up information, both of which AS lacks. I think these omissions contribute to the slightly lightweight vibe of AS, since the (almost invariably positive) "verdict" often seems to me less useful than other info in a review.
That said, Mceljo, I think most hobbyists would get a CDs worth of pleasure from a year of either mag.
John