All Amps Sound the Same....


A guy posted this on another forum:

"This is my other expensive hobby and while I agree with you about low end receivers, once you get to mid-priced (~$600-1000 street price) multichannel receivers you're into pretty good gear...Keep in mind that an amplifier sounds like an amplifier and changing brands should add or subtract nothing to/from the sound and that going up the food chain just adds power output or snob appeal to a separate amplifier...These days most audiophiles either use a good quality multichannel receiver alone or use a mid-priced multichannel receiver to drive their amps even for 2-channel."

Wow, where do they come up with this? Lack of experience?
128x128russ69
"but if you want to electronically reproduce music, then the measurements should be the dominate method of understanding."

Onhwy61 - In order to get pleasant sound from SS amplifier you need to elimnate TIM (transient intermodulation) distortion that enhances odd harmonics and cannot be easily measured. This TIM is created by negative feedback - same feedback that makes wide bandwidth, low output impedance, low THD and IMD. If you see extremely good measurements - run away.
Mrtennis, you are welcome. In answer to your question: Yes, I believe that
all music evokes an emotional response; anything that can fairly be called
music. It may not be a positive or pleasant response, but a response
nonetheless. Earlier you wrote that there is music of the brain, cerebral in
nature, and that does not necessarily evoke an emotional response. You
cited TWC as an example. Later you write:

***people are different in their reactions to music. i find the well tempered
clavier very helpful when solving mathematical problems.***

What is it then that causes this "help", if not an emotional
response?

BTW, a common discussion among musicians and musicologists is the
notion (by now, fairly well debunked) that Bach's music, particularly
TWC, is to be performed in a cold, mechanical (mathematical) fashion.
Not so. Additionally, it is also an accepted idea that in Bach's time a
tempo marking was an indication of the intended emotional character of
the music ("Allegro").
mrtennis

Perhaps the well tempered clavier stimulates the left side of your brain, without necessarily introducing any conscious perception of an "emotional" response?

A perfect cappucino in your favorite cafe might evoke an emotional response, but caffeine by itself is only a stimulant?

What other composers or music, please, would you recommend to enhance concentration and/or to prove that all amps do not sound the same.
I feel that Mrtennis invokes instigated contrast to fuel his narcissist mentality.
He can’t help it of course, but we all can.
in addition to bach, i would include purcell, scarlatti,froeberger, and other composers who wrote harpsichord music during the baroque period as very helpful when thinking is the sole activity.