Idol fans weigh in

Joshua is a screamer nothing more, justice has been served...Jessica is next.

My rig is down due to construction so Idol is my music fix...arrgghhh!

I agree with the posters here who like Jessica. I think she exhibits strength, intonation, and control like someone twice her age. Dave Mathews, I mean Philips, sounds (and looks) like nails scratching a chalkboard. Joshua over sings and chose a bad tune with 'Imagine".

But does anyone agree how pathetic Lisa Marie Presley's performance was? I think she thinks she's so cool. Her style and her voice are so gray and dull that is makes me mad. She's riding on her legendary father, for sure.

And Adam Lambart? He seemed very uncomfortable. He seemed nervous.

American Idol is fun and I love watching it. But if the Mathews clone wins, I'm not watching next season.

Funny how everyone has different tastes, I feel the same way about Jessica, if she wins I am out - her voice is too undeveloped. She will great great as she matures

Phillip is not a Matthews clone, he has a little Matthews, Cocker, Lamontagne, etc...

I would pay to see Phillip sing, I would pay to not have to hear Jessica and Joshua sing.

I wonder how Jackie Ivanchko would do on Idol. Except for Jennifer Hudson (sometimes), I have yet to hear a really good voice on Idol. And I would love to bitch-slap the panel, in its entirety. What a bunch of has-beens and poseurs they are...

-RW-

I told my wife that I think Jessica should win but I'd buy Phillip's records.