Yes, it's pretty normal for the TT to have somewhat higher relative position on the volume knob than the digital player. In your case, it is a bit more than usual, and I'd suspect that your phono stage gain is a slight bit too low for the ouput of that cartridge. You should be able to get strong sound at around the top of the dial(12 0'clock).
Welcome to analog!
Be prepared for people to say you are crazy that analog sounds better than digital.
Welcome to analog!
Be prepared for people to say you are crazy that analog sounds better than digital.