2. music
  3. 1060978544

Shostakovich...WHOA


An old g/f made a copy of a Shostakovich recording and until this week I’d never gotten around to it. MAN, is this guy giving me nightmares. I don’t know a damn thing about classical music but HOLY CHRISTMAS!

I can’t call up the old g/f to ask (I want to live, I want to live!) so I’m hoping someone can ID this recording and then offer suggestions to similar Shostakovich. I’m looking for brooding, scary, intense, hair-raising chaos…just like what’s-her-name.

The recording I was given has the following handwritten on it: “Kammersinfornie (after) string Quartet #8 & #10.” “1960” is also written on the recording with an arrow from it pointing to “Quartet #8.” The track most indicative of what I like is #2 whatever that is.

What’s this guy’s rep in the classical world, anyway? Maybe the style of this recording isn’t representative of his work.

As an interesting side note…this girl was always giving me really twisted material as witnessed by the title of the last book she gave me: “The Insanity of Normality – Realism as Sickness: Toward Understanding Human Destructiveness.” An army of red flags popped up with that one but I valiantly forged ahead with my little pea shooter anyway (please excuse the disgusting and humiliating metaphor.) I got clobbered.
kublakhan
rcprince
3,080 posts
 
Ljan, the 11th is indeed underperformed, it really requires a lot of concentration not only from the musicians but especially the audience. Most concertgoers stateswide aren't ready for that, certainly not the mainstream classical radio stations. Listened to the Cello Concerto No. 1 last night with its incredible cadenza between the second and third movements, definitely should add that to the list of pieces to hear, as well as the violin concerto (Hahn does a decent job with that, though there are better I'm sure). Shostakovich has a way with his slow movements of conveying great longing and emotion, always strike a chord with me.

By the way, what's with CDs gathering dust across the Pacific?
iasi
117 posts
 
Fitzwilliam Quartet and Borodin Quartet have recorded the best quartets of Shosti...for his Symphonies try 7 with Gergiev, 5&9 with Bernstein, 10 with Mravinsky...for his Violin Concerto 1 and Cello 1 try Mitropoulos with Oistrakh and Rostropovich...
shubertmaniac
350 posts
 
For a complete set of the string quartets, the best sounding are by the Emerson String Quartet, they either won or were nominated at the Grammys for their set. The Emersons are one of the best if not the best string quartet around, they are Shostakovich experts to boot. I think it was at one of the chamber music festivals, they played all 15 in either one or two days. They play with elan, their bow technique is unique, and their phrasing is original. A true best buy. They are on Deustch Grammophon, also the recordings are excellent, not second rate like most.
ljan
7 posts
 
Rcprince: I left my little collection of CDs overseas when I moved back to the states four, five years ago. I've been constantly moving for the past couple years so I guess it's a good idea that they weren't with me. I'm plotting to get them back when I can. I played the 11th with an awesome youth orchestra many years ago. Literally half the string section walked off stage after the concert weeping. I miss those days.

btw... you just can't go wrong with David Oistrakh. I haven't heard the Emerson Quartet in a long time but they gave a startling performance last time i heard them, even given the fact that the cellist or violinist started a couple measures late (LOL).
jax2
3,031 posts
 
The Emmerson Quartet that Shubertmaniac mentioned is also available as a single disk with only the 8th String Quartet played without pause. I believe it is the same version on the boxed set and is also on Deutsche Grammaphon. It is much cheaper than the boxed set if you are only after that one piece. I only mention it as it was the seed that started the whole thread. Here is the Amazon Listing
I have not heard it so cannot comment on the performance or quality of the recording.
More to discover