Capturing the MUSIC; a furtive cause? What R We...


...missing when we listen to recorded music in our homes?

There's been a lot of talk lately -- and not so lately -- about the empirical (listening) vs. the scientific (measurable) EFFECTS regarding a number of things not least of which is changing the connecting wires in a reproduction network.

Rather than regurgitate the whole gamut of conflicting argumentation bandied around, I thought I'd just provide a link to an interesting reproduction (sorry for the pun) of a seminar by J. Boyk* at Caltech: "Capturing Music: The Impossible Task".

It's a short and interesting read.

For those who have already read this, pls excuse the redundancy in favour of those that haven't.

In this abstract Boyk touches on MUSIC, the difficult task of recording & reproducing music correctly --i.e. as the musician intended it to be heard -- and the diffulties inherent in trying to gauge or measure "QUALITY" of the recording & reproducing equipment.

Many interesting points made. Rather than expand further & waste server space, I'll just reproduce (that word again!) a nice little paragraph from the abstract:
A ...friend ...won the Westinghouse Science Talent Search in high school with his work on hearing; and continued in the field through a doctorate and professorship; but now works on vision. "Why the change?" I asked. "Listen!" he said, "In vision, at least we know what the questions are!"

I'd be interested in any comments &/or feedback. Cheers!

*Mr Boyk is a pianist, a lecturer at Caltech, and also does consulting work in related fields. He studied Maths.
gregm
live music is a reference. a stereo system and a recording are flawed. both have "errors". the "sound" emanating from from one's speakers should please its owner, hopefully, regardless of its fidelity to the real thing.

please your ear and don't worry about anything else. music can be therapeutic if it doesn't bother you.
Dear Greg, didn't realize you were still around, saw your post about snake oil and wires. I still think your questions above are valid and I must say, that I still like my response. Sad, that it was all squashed and shut up by drab common sense.
Complacency will probably never be our own, will it?
Cheers,
Hallo Detlof, I was happy to see you return to these cyber-shores.
I'll try a PM and hope it reaches you.
In my ever ripening age, I am more and more convinced that complacency is a waste of life...:)