Revel Salon 2 versus WP 8

Henryhk,

It looks like you compared the W/P8 to the old Revel Salon and not the Salon2? Your System thread doesn't say you demoed the Salon2 as far as I can tell. Is that correct?

Thanks.

Jkalman,
Have you considered one of Sonus Fabers infinite baffle sources; Elipsa or Stradivarius to mitigate the effect of your room? Sorry if off topic, my intent is not to start a rash of speaker recommendations..... Also, thanks for sharing your quest.

I have thought about it, but those are much harder speakers to find in order to get a demo.

Jkaalman,

I am not sure but I think you can change the resistor values on the tweeter section of the WP8 if you want to attenuate the highs or increase the highs. Not sure, but I have read threads of people using a different resistor set on the WP / Maxx IIs based on their preferences.

On a different note: w. Maxx IIs I also have bass problems. Of course room related. Next on my list.

I tried placement changes, a single subwoofer to augment the bass etc. Nothing helped. I was thinking stereo subs should do the trick but never tried it. I saw subwoofers in your system. Do your measurements include your subwoofers? I am sure if the WP8s are setup perfectly based on wasp parameters bass will roll off a little early. A subwoofer will help a lot.

Finally, how many concert halls attenuate bass? I know a crowded room sounds better than an empty one. Maybe more seating, and furniture might help.

Dgad,

The measurements don't include the subwoofers. If I hook my Revel Sub 30s in and crossover at 80Hz I can eliminate all of the bass issues from 80Hz to below. The subs also have built in PEQ, so I can get a very flat response if I go that way. I currently only have them hooked into the surround potion of my setup. If I hook them into my two channel setup I will have to use them all the time or manually shut them off. I do know from listening to two channel through my surround setup that it does improve the bottom end.

Concert halls are usually big enough that bass doesn't become an issue. The modes are spread out so much. That and they usually do a much more thorough job acoustically since the space is designed for audio from the moment of conception (dimensions and all). My room was a pre-existing space.