Look for one that allows flexibility. Phase controls, a good xover range, volume, good power amp, high and low pass filters, (for now and later), and the right size for your room.
I have a 14x21x8 roughly, sized room... I've had 9, 10, 12, and now a 15 inch sub in it. All the speakers running with it didn't go below about 35hz or so, some even fell off sooner at 40-45, or more... if I could afford it I'd have one more likewise 15, or a pair of other 15 inchers, but a pair do seem to be the ticket... although one does a pretty dog gone good job.
I've always ran subs with RCA ICs out from the preamp and/or processor. I like sealed units which are front firing more so too than downfiring and ported subs.
Take a gander at Rel, HSU, Velodyne and SVS, in no particular order.
When it comes to subs... size does matter and depends greatly on the room's cubic footage as well.
Good luck