Joseph Audio Pulsars v. Focal Diablo Utopia's


I have been looking for a pair of Joseph Audio Pulsars to replace my JA 25XL's (which I already like) I've never heard the Pulsars but I like the "Joseph sound" and have seen how everyone raves about them. However, I recently heard some Focal's and wondered if anyone had any thoughts on how the Focal Diablo Utopia's compare with the Pulsars . . . I've got a Theta Dreadnaught 5 channel amp, with a Plinius SA 103 2 channel for the front speakers, and a Marantz 8801 preamp, with Cardas Golden Cross wire for the fronts and Audience Au24's for the center and interconnects. Thoughts?
moto_man
I owned the prior Focal Utopia be model and now own the Pulsars. Both are excellent speakers. I doubt I will part with the Pulsars anytime soon.
If it is within your budget I would look for a used pair of Raidho C1.1s. I used to own the Pulsars. They sounded great -- until the Raidhos joined my system. The Raidhos are on a whole different level. No comparison.
For the price of the Focals you could almost be looking at the JA Perspectives. Anyway, I think the fact that you like the JA house sound is a good indicator although certainly not definitive. Also, the Focal tweeter is very different from the treble you get from a JA fabric dome, so that would be something to look for upon comparison. Markalarsen probably has some good insight to the differences between the two although he had a previous Focal model. These are not huge speakers, so if you have dealers of both nearby I'd arrange for an in-home demo and you'll have your answer pretty quickly I'd think. Personally I think the Pulsar is a much better looking speaker if that's even a consideration, although you may feel differently. By the way, just out of curiosity, what's your center speaker?

One last thought. Whatever you ultimately choose and given the quality of your amp I'd strongly recommend trying a good stereo preamp that could be seamlessly integrated into your surround system. As good as the 8801 may be, it could very well be a significant bottleneck to the performance you can ultimately achieve for stereo. IME the preamp is one of the most important contributors to a system's sound, so it's at least worth a look. Anyway, best of luck in your search.