asp307,
I would plug the amp into the other duplex receptacle, jmho. I would have both the phono preamp and amp plugged into the same duplex. Analog and analog go together just fine.
The CDP would be plugged in the other duplex receptacle. Problem with both the CDP and amp being plugged in the same duplex receptacle, there is a greater chance of digital hash/noise traveling back out on the CDP power cord and re-entering the power cord and power supply of the analog power amp. (Coupling the digital CDP power supply to the power amp's power supply.)
Granted both duplexes are fed from the same branch circuit but they are separated by what ever the lengths of the two spurs of NM-B cable from the junction box below the floor to each wall duplex receptacle outlet. Every little bit helps.
You may not hear any difference the way you have it now. After you get the four receptacles of the two duplexes burned-in you could then experiment having both the CDP and amp plugged into the same duplex receptacle and then separate them as I described above. Listen for any differences in sound.