2. analog
  3. 125781-22211

Which cartridge should I upgrade to now?

Hi folks,

My Shelter 501 Mk 11 cartridge needs replacing after years of  wonderful service. What I get next will be going onto an RB250 arm with a Half Moon counterweight, that sits on a Nottingham Analog Studios Horizon table.

I haven't thought exhaustively about this yet, but my current candidates are a Denon DL 103R, & perhaps one of the Hana cartridges, maybe the EL or the SH, based purely on the rave reviews. The SH in particular is double the cost of what I can get the Denon for ($330 AUD {Australian dollars} with free shipping), but I'm prepared to pay the extra if the difference is thought to be substantial. 

I'd prefer to not spend more than about $500 USD, which with the current exchange rate & shipping will translate into about $750 AUD. I'm happy to hear your opinions, not only on these cartridges, but other candidates you deem worthy.

Thanks!

houseofhits
jperry
2,444 posts
 
In the USA I have used Soundsmith and Phono Cartridge Retipping both with excellent results. In England, Expert Stylus does retipping, with good reviews, but I don't have personal experience. Just type cartridge retipping in google or Audiogon for additional comments and their websites.

That Rega tonearm is good for the money, but will not let you achieve optimal performance from your phono cartridge.
houseofhits OP
11 posts
 
Ok thanks for the info. Re tonearms, what do suggest as a replacement for the RB250? Not in a position to spend four figures on an arm. Second hand is probably the go for me.
chayro
2,974 posts
 
I don't think anything you're talking about will be as good as the Shelter.  The Denons are OK, but that's about it.  Personally, in the budget range, I think the Goldring Eroica is very good and I know it works well in Rega arms.  Good luck. 
johnnyb53
3,510 posts
 
Garrott Brothers retipping service has been owned and operated since 1992 by Audio Dynamics in Melbourne, AU.
You can also facilitate a Garrison retip through Decibel Hi-Fi. The linked page includes their retipping rates, which are well within your budget and give you back your cartridge worth around $1700 AU.
mattmiller's avatar
mattmiller
1,493 posts
 
I would not replace a Shelter 501 with a Denon 103 AND the 103 is not a good cartridge for that light to med weight tone arm. A much better choice would be a Dynavector 10X5 MC (2.5mv) for that arm, IMO. Lots of jump factor with this cartridge, you cant go wrong. Keep your tonearm and change to a proper cartridge is my advice. Also, I agree re tipping the Shelter might be the best option IF your changing your tonearm (only use Soundsmith for that, imo), but that Dynavector is really nice with that arm.

Matt M
More to discover