Vandersteen Treo vs 3A Sig as upgrade


I had my local dealer hook up a pair of Treos to demo them and left with a very mixed impression. I like the overall sound. They have a smoother, more refined and sophisticated midrange that the 3A Sigs can't match. I want that. But the bass was less defined and the top end was bright. The sibilance was very exaggerated - this was with CD. Is this the character of the Treo? Thanks!
wlutke
@mr_m;  I have the Rogue CM2 integrated amp.  I have contacted Rogue a couple of times and found them to be very responsive.


Regards.  Richard in Tucson




I've scheduled an extended audition  of the Treo CT and the Proac 30R next week.  The same dealer carries both. I am narrowing my choices to these two...at least for the moment.  I will report the results of my listening session.  I'm in the process now of selecting music.
Funny Randy as I was a Proac guy and did that audition (before the ribbon  tweeter) and became a Vandy guy.  Are you in NJ or Dallas? I think those are the two who carry both? lol
Dallas....and I will listening to the "R" version.  I had a pair of Proac Response 1sc for an extended loan about 15 years ago.  I loved the sound of those little stand mounts. I have been interested in auditioning the larger Proacs ever since.  I haven't heard the Treo in a number of years..and it was not the CT version.  I don't think the dealer in Dallas has a pair of Quatros to demo at this time.
I heard those 30R's that you will be auditioning, lol.  I actually bought the Linn Kiko system he had as he wanted to get rid of it and I wanted something for the bedroom.  It's worked ok.

I personally think the Vandersteens are much more detailed, dynamic, realistic etc...  I don't love the Proac bass.  I never did and I have owned three pair for over 20 years. I recently sold all of them.  I still like the Proac's and there is a reason so many Vandersteen dealers carry ProAc also.  Their ribbon is the sweetest Iv'e heard honestly. I like it better than so many of the esoteric 30k plus ribbons.  That's just me, but the CT Vandersteen's magic mids win out.  The presentation is about 20 rows back and not upfront.  I personally like that as it allows the music to mature and I like air around the notes, just like it is at Carnegy Hall or the local Infinity venue we like to go to.  It will be interesting to hear what your thoughts are. 

Last year they had a pair of Zebrawood Quatro's that were gorgeous.  I am still thinking I may go with that veneer when I order mine.  Either that or I may have them upgrade to heavy metal flake dark Crimson.  I think I'd love that look in my room and I'm not selling for a long time so I don't care if folks don't want to buy that look, lol.  The Treo CT's are special speakers.  If you loved the Proac's like I have/do, I think you are in for a treat, unless the guy showing them likes the Proac's better.  I always always keep in mind that the dealers make more on selling Proac's so they often try to steer us that way ;)....Things to always keep in mind when purchasing, lol....you obviously know what you are doing randy.  I've followed your posts, so it will be neat to hear about your auditioning....I forget the guy I worked with there, but I went to OU and have sent them a lot of business over the years.  he was a younger guy I think.   I'd  tell you to say hi for me, lol.