What SS preamp compares to a tube preamp

I'm not sure I want to make this change, but only exploring options. I would like to keep this purchase under $3000 new or used and I think that's about the price point to make it worthwhile.....not sure though.
0
I started with a few AVR's, then went to a B&K ref 50 which is very nice, finally to a VTL 2.5. I'm currently using the VTL but with the price of some tubes I'm considering going back to solid state. I have a few tubes that sound really nice, Mullard 4003, 4024, 1950's Siemens, Valvo, Brimar, etc....I have found good sound but there's always a compromise. Once I hit the right mid range, I lose some top end, sometimes vice-versa. Also the gain on the 2.5 is excessive, fair amount of hiss and I know tube rush is a side effect but this is just excessive gain... 20 db. I have tried attenuators but they take a little top end from the sound.

I'm not giving up on tubes, but just would like to hear what others have tried that have been in this situation. I don't need HDMI but would be nice, mainly would like a remote. I don't think an AVR can do what I want but maybe a dedicated preamp.

I thought about an Anthem but they have mixed reviews.....not really sure where to look.

All input and criticism appreciated.

dyl7111-18-2016 12:07am

...
49 posts total
View entire discussion

jtsnead Details Discussions Posts This discussion Message User 217 posts 11-19-2016 at 08:37pm Copy Comment URL Report Comment Edit Delete You might want to look at the Audio Research preamps using the 6h30 tube they have nice sound and last a long time, I have the LS17SE and it works great also has balanced in and outs can get a good price on a used one
dlcockrum Details Discussions Posts This discussion Message User 2,190 posts 11-19-2016 at 08:41pm Copy Comment URL Report Comment Edit Delete All of the above are exceptionally fine components. The differences between the best tube and SS gear per se is less than the differences between house sounds of each. It is a matter of personal preference, flexibility, and system compatibility as to which will work best for you/me.
charles1dad Details Discussions Posts This discussion Message User 10,249 posts 11-19-2016 at 10:56pm Copy Comment URL Report Comment Edit Delete Mb1 audio, Yes, go listen to Krell, Vitus, Soulution and Spectral . All four are transistor electronics yet they are strikingly different from one another. Which is more accurate? Charles
zavato Details Discussions Posts This discussion Message User 1,397 posts 11-19-2016 at 11:51pm Copy Comment URL Report Comment Edit Delete For years I ran tubes. Conrad Johnson then Rogue. 3 years ago I went over to Pass Labs. Same as tubes? Unlikely but I do not miss the tubes even one bit. Pass is that good
waxwaves Details Discussions Posts This discussion Message User 206 posts 11-23-2016 at 01:52am Copy Comment URL Report Comment Edit Delete If you don't want the tube hassle, but still want full bodied accurate lifelike sound, then I bet you'll like a McIntosh SS preamp. The control it can give you over the listening space and inferior recordings is a nice bonus, and has certainly added to my musical enjoyment. I have used several highly reviewed modern preamps in your price range, tube and SS. I have a good bit of experience with the preamp you are using now. As always, YMMV and good luck.