Class D Technology


So I get the obvious strengths of Class D. Efficiency, power output & running cool which allows for small form factors. I also understand the weaknesses somewhat. 1. Non-linear & lots of distortion that needs to be cleaned up with an output filter. 
So my question is, if it weren't for efficiency & power, would there be any reason to own a Class D amp? Do they beat Class A in any other categories that count for sound quality?  
seanheis1
Thanks for the link Tim. This quote tickled me.
Much the same with converters. If you know exactly what to look out for in a chip, you can find chips that are really suited for use in a $1000 product that, for the price, will offer fantastic performance, simply incredible value. Speakers ditto: You wouldn’t believe the performance of some $10 drive-units, but if you’re hung up on exotic cone materials, you just won’t discover those.

savdllc

I'm afraid I don't buy your premise that class D is always behind A/B, or even behind class A universally. I'm listening to class D precisely because they were as good as heavily class A biased linear amplifiers, though just like linear amps, I can see them having limitations with specific difficult to drive speakers.

Further, I don't buy that ranking tech in order really helps us understand sound quality very much at all. I assure you I can make a terrible sounding class A amplifier. :D

I think while it's cool, and fun to understand what's different, and how compromises and problems are solved, and how dac X is different than dac Y, I'm not one who puts this above personal impressions.

Best,

Erik
savdllc,

     You stated: " but if one is chasing greater efficiency than Class A without sacrificing as much fidelity as Class D tends to do, Class G and H amplifier tech would seem to be the best choice."

     This statement implies that class D requires you to sacrifice significant fidelity when compared to class A/B.  As a user of various decent quality  class A/B amps exclusively for about 30 yrs (beginning with Adcom and then McCormak and  most recently Aragon) before trying various good quality class D amps (beginning 2 yrs ago with a budget ClassD Audio SDS440SC  then an Emerald Physics EP-100.2SE and currently D-Sonic M3-600-M mono-blocks), I can assure you I never felt I was sacrificing any fidelity with class D.  

    With all 3 class D amps I actually experienced quite the opposite; immediately noticing significant improvements in noise level, bass response, mid-treble fidelity being very similar to class A/B with my initial budget class D and clearly superior to my former class A/B amps with my admittedly better quality most recent class D amps.

     I know there are many here on Audiogon who have discovered  switching to class D is all gain with honestly no pain.   I'm concerned that comments like yours, and other posters earlier in this thread, may give readers the false impression that switching to class D involves some sacrifices in sound quality.
      I want to make it clear to everyone considering a switch from class A/B to class D amplification that these sort of comments may have been accurate for some early lower quality class D amps but are definitely not valid for current good quality class D amps.  

     Once you've experienced the extraordinary improvements a good recent class D amp will make in your system, you'll begin to realize how inaccurate, no longer relevant and simply untrue these types of comments are.    

     I can only rationalize these sorts of comments by assuming that these individuals have obviously never auditioned a recent good quality class D amp in their system or anywhere else.  Although it's possible  they're just parroting comments they've heard years ago about early examples of class D. 

     I'm grateful I ignored these class D myths and opted for an open minded home trial and suggest others do the same.

    Concerning class G and H, I have never heard either but I'm interested in hearing them.  Being an extension of class A and A/B amps, however, I would expect them not to have the same advantages of reduced weight and size that class D allows.

Thanks,
  Tim
Classes G, h have the same advantages of reduced weight and size that class D allows to a lesser extent.  The power supply is "variable" based on the signal.

BTW, is the highly rated Benchmark AHB2 amp considered Class D?