Synergistic Red Fuse ...

Kedoades 1-14-2017
Hello, I am thinking of trying one of these black fuses. I see some people are recommending that you go one size up on the fuse, just wondering if this is always safe to do? thanks

Based on the several reports we have seen in this thread of SR Black fuses blowing when they shouldn’t, it seems clear that the unspecified "melting point" of SR Blacks is lower than that of typical stock fuses having the same current rating. ("Melting point" defines the combination of current and duration that if exceeded would cause a fuse to blow, and is expressed in units of amps-squared x seconds). Therefore it seems clear that if for example you were to substitute a "5 amp" SR Black for a 5 amp stock fuse you would in effect be substituting a fuse having a lower rating than 5 amps.

Also, from a technical standpoint it seems to me to be very unlikely that a fault in a component that should cause a fuse to blow would result in a current draw just slightly above the rating of the stock fuse. Especially in the case of a mains fuse, but most likely also in the case of DC rail fuses.

On the other hand, it might be argued that use of a higher fuse rating than stock could invalidate warranty and/or insurance coverage. But that too seems very unlikely. And in any event the same argument could be made even if the same rating as the stock fuse is used, just based on the fact that the upgraded fuse does not have approval from UL and other such agencies.

So IMO there is no problem going up one or two current rating increments. Although some others have expressed differing opinions earlier in the thread, and the post just above indicates that going up one or two increments may not always be enough anyway.

Regards,
-- Al

Hi Al,

Is it possible that the same electrical characteristics that create the audible differences from these fuses also create the issues with them failing in certain circumstances? 

Best to you Al,
Dave

Hi Dave.

I suppose it's possible that there is some relation between the apparently lower melting points of the SR Blacks, compared to typical stock fuses, and the sonic benefits that have been reported.  But in the absence of a good technical understanding of why and how those benefits occur, that stands up when looked at quantitatively, and that accounts for the high degree of consistency that has been reported for those benefits among very diverse applications, I doubt that the question is answerable.

Best regards,
-- Al
   

Fair enough Al. Thanks as always.

Dave

UNBELIEVABLE!  This "Synergistic"  fuse company selling products so poorly manufactured----- they can't even get the fuse rating right !
 High quality fuse manufacturers such as BUSSMANN  and  LITTELFUSE ,who supply to high tech industries, would be bankrupted with claims. Charlatans and snake oil peddlars should be asshamed of themselves.......