low power tube amp


I am purchasing some new speakers. The manufacturer recommends 40w-200w for the speakers.

I am using a low power 20wpc Class A SET amp.  I worry that the low wattage may damage the speakers.

Is my concern valid?  I heard tube amp wattage is not the same as solid state.  Can someone clarify?

thanks in advance
128x128klee123
Charles,

You’d be hard-pressed to find a lesser-quality tube amp than mine!* It retailed new for a thousand bucks, with a pair of monitor speakers bundled for free.

That said, it is an over-achieving little beast. :-)

*Perhaps this sentence has never been written before on Audiogon. ;-)


Hi Cymbop.
Quality can be had for reasonable cost as your amplifier demonstrates. It couldn’t handle your speakers if it lacked good solid design and parts. High quality parts don’t always have to imply expensive. For me the true test of quality is actual performance as opposed to price tag. 
Charles
The Focal Sopra 2 is specified at 91 db/2.83 volts/1 meter, with a nominal impedance of 8 ohms and a minimum impedance of 3.1 ohms. Based in part on my experience some years ago with a high quality 18 watt tube amp and 90 db speakers having fairly benign impedance characteristics, listening to classical music having wide dynamic range in many cases, I would expect that for many (but certainly not all) users 20 high quality watts would be adequate. However a greater concern IMO would be the sonic synergy between the amp and the speaker.

Specifically, impedance curves I’ve seen at Stereophile for several Focal speakers, which in most cases are specified similarly to the Sopra 2 in terms of sensitivity and impedance characteristics, show impedances of 3 to 4 ohms in much of the bass region, and much higher impedances at higher frequencies.

The interaction of that kind of impedance variation with the relatively high output impedance of most single-ended tube amps will result in weaker bass and over-emphasized mids and highs, compared to many other tube amps and nearly all solid state amps. Although if your amp provides a 4 ohm tap the degree of that impedance interaction will be reduced somewhat, compared to an 8 ohm or higher impedance tap.

Good luck. Regards,
-- Al

Hi Al,
Agree with your assessment. Given that this is a KT 88 amp there may be some judicious use of NFB (lowering the output impedance) which "may" be beneficial along with a 4 ohm tap. An audition if possible will settle his case. If unable to audition then the safer choice would be a higher power push pull tube amplifier or solid state.
Charles