It will be very hard to make a decision without have them in your own house side by side and all but make some notes and listen to the same recordings. Get to know the cymbals and piano and then male and female voice etc... Where are you sitting in the hall....I never understood components that put you IN with the band or orchestra, lol.
Have fun with it all and listen as a system to make sure it's what you can get out of your own. Also listen with top of the line components to see how much better your speakers can sound as you upgrade in the future. Keep us posted. Two speakers you list are a good start for sure.