@imhififan Some pp cap has >50% voltage derating when operating temperature over 85 ºC , that could be the possible reason Mark Levinson recommend replacing them with Ceramic X7R .01uF @ 200vI could see that. So you prompted me to look up derating tables for Ceramic. Got a little lesson on cap classifications as well. Here are some quotes from TDK:
A Class I capacitor* (C0G, C0H, C0K, etc.) is made from ceramic materials that are not sensitive to temperature changes, thus the capacitance value of a capacitor measured at a low temperature (example -25°C) will not significantly vary from the same capacitor measured at a higher temperature (ex. 75°C).
EIA refers to these as “temperature compensating,” and are measured in ppm/°C.
These capacitors typically have low capacitance values because of the ceramic material used to manufacture them but they exhibit nearly perfect capacitance stability regardless of their temperature, making them an excellent choice for applications in which frequency control is needed such as in radio or television tuners.
A Class II capacitor2 (X7R, Y5V, Z5U) is made from ceramic materials that are derived from a barium titanate base which is temperature sensitive. Thus the various temperature classifications stating the extent of the sensitivity over a given temperature range. These capacitors allow for larger capacitance values in the small surface mount packages.
Additionally, capacitors made from barium titanate bases (Class II, III, and IV) are ferroelectric and therefore susceptible to “aging” in which a capacitor’s ability to hold capacitance will decrease over time if left in an unheated and/or uncharged state. Class I capacitors are not ferroelectric and therefore do not age.
So I am not trying to beat a dead horse here. If we are going to dialogue about this then lets do just that. Today I learned things that I did not know yesterday and that is always a good thing.
I tried to see if the caps I need could be found with a C0G designation but caps of such small capacitance were not available with that designation.
I started to prep my monster for the eminent surgery. I still have the option of going PP or ceramic. I still also have an open mind about it. There is no real rush. So you know when you go to a fancy restaurant starving and they bring out the entree and it is a smaller than your appetite? That’s how I feel when I look at the cap comparison in this photo:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B0yvjhlC62G7aGVRZzYzLTVaUEU/view?usp=sharing
It just looks like something is missing :)
I bought 15 of these Vishay ceramics X7R from Mouser. They were really inexpensive.
Mouser also has a 250v PP Vishay cap that will work which is about $1.22 each.
Here is what will really get your grey matter baking....There are identical PP caps sprinkled on the current gain board yet ML did not make those cap changes mandatory. The current gain board is the heat generating furnace yet they don’t seem concerned that those PP caps are steadily being warmed. They only focused on the voltage gain board. Things that make you go hmmmmmm.