Best Drum Solos


I'm finding that I've been REALLY enjoying drum solos on my system lately. They seem to work the whole speaker, from the kick drum in the woofers, to the tom-tom in the midrange, and the cymbals and high hats in the tweeters. And when it all comes together, they are the instrument I have the easiest time seeing in front of myself.

I searched the forums titles to see if there were any good drum solo discussions going on, but I didn't see any. So here we go. In no particular order, here are some drum solos I've found to be very high quality:

Art Blakey & The Jazz Messengers - The Drum Thunder Suite
Art Blakey & The Jazz Messengers - Caravan
Dave Brubeck Quartet - Far More Drums
Led Zeppelin - Moby Dick
Max Roach - Max's Variations

What are your favorite drum solos to listen to on your system? 
128x128heyitsmedusty
Very pleased you liked it, bdp. We can put aside our differences about Ginger and agree on Gadd. He seems on another plane altogether. I’m not a drummer but would say there is something about Gadd’s style that is very nuanced and almost delicate yet powerful without bashing. Kind of deceptive that way. And very very quick. I’m sure you see and hear more in it than I do. Humbling is okay. Got to have high goals to aspire to. That whole performance from all participants achieves an amazing level of excellence. Bears lots of re-watching.

gh, Steve Gadd is a very technically trained drummer (in rudiments, the equivalent of a guitarist, bassist, or pianist knowing all the scales of every key in every position. The Band bassist Rick Danko said organist Garth Hudson’s advice to learn them was the best he was ever given), having studied at both The Eastman and Manhattan Schools of Music, as well as having played in the U.S. Army Stage Band. His famous part in Paul Simon’s "50 Ways To Leave Your Lover" is very militaristic. He was already sitting in with world-class Jazz artists as a teenager.

Steve uses his incredible technique as a means to precisely and cleanly execute his very musical drum ideas and parts, not to merely display that technique. He doesn’t overplay, a rarity amongst highly technical players. His technical abilities allow him to play with a great deal of finesse and delicacy (it’s hard to play drums quietly! The Band’s Levon Helm is great at that), yet also play a thunderously dynamic crescendo or solo.

Speaking of solo, his are very musical---with an intro, a theme established, a variation on that theme played, followed by another theme, an eventual finale, etc. Lots of structure, and musically interesting and lyrical ideas, not the mere athletic performance that is typical in the vast majority of drummer’s solos. It was for the same reason I cited Don Lamond’s solo (actually, a short drum "break") in Bobby Darin’s studio recording of "Beyond The Sea", as musical (and humorous!) a drum solo as I’ve ever heard.

In addition, Gadd plays with a lot of dynamics, letting the song, singer, and other musicians tell him when to hit hard and loud, and when to bring it way down, playing his bass drum with the "feathered" technique I explained in a previous post. Many drummers play with almost no dynamics, giving every note the same dynamic value---eleven! Some music calls for that---Keith Moon in The Who had little choice in the matter, not that he cared ;-).

And lastly, Steve’s drums and cymbals sound great; he learned how to tune drums (you’d be surprised how many don’t, including Buddy Rich), and knew how to pick out good brass---his cymbals are really good sounding ones, though not as good as those of Jim Gordon and Levon Helm, the two best sets I’ve ever heard. Again, very "musical" sounding---the overtones in tune with the fundamentals---harmonic, not dissonant. The sound of cymbals, by the way, is greatly influenced and determined by the manner in which they are played. Ringo’s and Keith Moon’s cymbal sound was very "washy", as they both played them with the "shoulder" of the stick, not it’s tip. I love the "click" produced by the tip of a small drumstick hitting a thin cymbal, the click greatly enhanced in recording with the application of heavy compression on the mic recording the cymbal. It makes the stick tip-on-cymbal impact really "POP!" If the engineer isn't already doing it when I record now, I request he do so.

bdp - Thank you very much for that analysis. I enjoy learning the details behind a great music performance. I spent a lot of hours in my youth with Signore Clementi (for better or worse), so can appreciate some of the concepts. I think Gadd’s broad dynamics might be one of his traits I picked up on most readily (i.e., "nuanced") - that and his inventiveness. Thanks again. I appreciate the time you spent writing.

Here's a few you may not have heard.  
 Dafnis Prieto - https://youtu.be/O_aUuzMeLkM

Gergo Borlai - https://youtu.be/3w0JZpaHDz4

Giovanni Hidalgo - https://youtu.be/Ne3oSLlRiZU

These guys give new meaning to the phrase "talking drums"!  More like singing, sometimes screamin'!;)
My pleasure, ghosthouse. There are plenty of other drummers with highly developed technique, but that alone is no guarantee of good drumming. It is that ability in combination with musical creativity and good taste that makes Gadd the drummer he is. Another was Johnny Barbata, as I previously mentioned. He was an L.A. studio drummer who was enlisted into The Turtles, and though the other Turtles were nothing special, he was very special. Listen to his playing in "Happy Together", "She’d Rather Be With Me", and "You Know What I Mean". Really cool parts that take a fair degree of technique to play (Buddy Rich was a fan of Johnny’s). Levon Helm had a fair amount of technique, along with off-the-charts musicality, taste, and creativity. He could play a "press-roll", which Ringo has yet to learn. That’s okay, Keith Moon couldn’t play one either, but both had their own style, and did pretty well without technique! The pursuit of technique as an end unto itself can lead to a style of playing that in nothing more than the vulgar display of athletic ability. It is only in the service of making music that it has true value.