First of all, if you bother to educate yourself on routine care of an LP, and if you acquire decent equipment with which to play them, your experience with ticks and pops would never be repeated. What you experienced was the result of abuse. Either your cartridge was badly worn or your set-up was way off such that the stylus was damaging your LPs as you played them. I hasten to add that this does not make you a bad person. If you spend some time learning about this discipline, you will learn what to do and what not to do to avoid repeating your old experience. First rule of thumb is that second hand LPs, unless you know and trust the source, probably will benefit from a good cleaning BEFORE the needle hits the groove. Playing a dirty LP can per se damage it.
Nearly half of my 2500 LPs were purchased used and most of the rest I have owned for 30-40 years. I don't tolerate ticks and pops unless they occur only rarely. Most of my LPs offer background noise as low as the medium permits, and that is actually quite low, certainly low enough to be no issue as far as my listening pleasure. Anything that's noisy enough to bug me goes into the trash. I can count on two hands the number of LPs that I have had to discard for that reason in the last 10 years. (That's less than 10 out of many hundreds that I have listened to.)