2. analog
  3. 134244-10289

TO BE OR NOT TO BE the user of a record clamp

I'm going to open a new can of worms that will make you sure, I just can't hear.  Please give me good reasons to use a record clamp.  I have seen them advertised for thousands of dollars.  The best reason I've heard so far is that a certain type will drain any electo-static energy from your LP.
My records are not warped, except for an occasional waver on some when looking at record level at the outer most portion of the it, and those are far and few between.  Even then, the clamp has no affect,on flattening out the record.  I can see where they may be very useful, when playing a warped LP, but other than that, I see no reason for it's use.  I can see where it makes a good solid connection to the platter.  I don't have any slip, when the record is playing.  Maybe I have it, but just can't see it.  Are they like seat belts on a car?  Better to use them than not?  Are they like a properly mounted speaker.  It needs to be very solid?  I can understand that.  The record more or less becomes part of the platter.  They become as one.  Be sure to read this last part, because as I'm writing this, I can see where it can actually makes the platter solidly attached to the record.  I think I just answered my own question.  But thousands of dollars for a clamp?  I have talked to several people, trying to explain how tweeks, not matter how small, add them all together an wow.
handymann
spotcheckbilly12345
30 posts
 
I own several warped old (but kinda rare) LP's that are very difficult to replace. I use a lightweight Michell record clamp when listening to these LP's. This clamp, when used correctly, allows me to enjoy them when they were unplayable before using the clamp. For an investment of about $50 the Michell is well worth it. Otherwise, I do not use a clamp or record weight (I also own a Bren1 weight, but it hardly sees any use).

I believe that the use of a weight or clamp depends on things like system synergy (does it play well with your 'table, etc?) and the condition of your LP's.

Cheers,
              SB
geoffkait's avatar
geoffkait
23,365 posts
 
Some are clamps, some are dampers, some are mass loaders, and some are resonators. Even a relatively inexpensive Mpingo disc can be quite impressive just sitting there, right side up of course. 
lewm
12,524 posts
 
I used to be a confirmed nonbeliever in weights OR clamps.  Then I tried my SOTA reflex clamp on one of my turntables (I don't even remember which one), and I heard a big improvement.  I also have the OEM record weight that was supplied with my Kenwood L07D.  It weighs maybe 0.5 lbs or less.  I use it on my Lenco/BA Mat2 and on my Victor TT101 (and on the L07D which has a stainless steel platter "sheet").  I think the mat (i.e., the surface upon which the LP sits) is a major determinant of whether or not you can gain something by using a weight or clamp.  The ear/brain rules this decision.
melm
1,057 posts
 
What made a real difference for me was the use of a peripheral clamp together with a center clamp.  That takes you to another level of clamping!  Great if your TT can take the weight.
pryso
1,909 posts
 
miketuason, and possibly handymann, if you demand "scientific proof" then I think you are in the wrong hobby.  For how many years now has debate raged over tube/ss, analog/digital, dynamic speakers/planar/horn, and so on?  Has there been scientific proof to absolutely resolve any one of those?  So why should tt weights or clamps be any different?

As may have stated, perceptions can vary from one table to another.  Even then, personal preferences can't be eliminated.
More to discover