fsonicsmith, "When a reviewer automatically dismisses analogue as a faulty medium or insists upon truthful reproduction of the lowest octave of pipe-organ or double-bass, I know to steer clear."
I share your skepticism with commercial reviewers, while appreciating Dudley. But I'm confused by your statement quoted above. The pipe-organ has the potential for a 16 Hz note which a cartridge may not track. But the double-bass (4-string string bass) low reach is 42 Hz. Any decent cartridge should reproduce that.
And yes, I prefer analog for sonic enjoyment.