No, it does not necessarily mean that you have a phonostage that is behaving like Atmasphere described; you are utilizing extreme loading (22 ohms) which would prevent overloading from ultrasonic signals, and to some extent, the sharp transients of a tick or pop. You should try your current setup with the loading set at 47k ohms (or totally unloaded, if that option is available) to see what happens. Just experiment with all loading options, and with each setting, leave it at that setting for some time so that your ear/brain gets acclimated to the new sound.
To me, utilizing high loading (low value of resistor) takes away a lot of what one hopes to get out of moving from run of the mill MM cartridges to a MC cartridge--the vibrancy, liveliness and top end extension is wiped away. If your set up sounds "wrong" with more modest loading, such as 100 ohms, something might be wrong elsewhere.
To me, utilizing high loading (low value of resistor) takes away a lot of what one hopes to get out of moving from run of the mill MM cartridges to a MC cartridge--the vibrancy, liveliness and top end extension is wiped away. If your set up sounds "wrong" with more modest loading, such as 100 ohms, something might be wrong elsewhere.