Does hearing the best in high end audio make your opinions more valid?


I say yes. Some say no. What are your thoughts?
calvinj
Actually, the LS3/5a is not the really the best example to try to make your case with as it was notoriously inefficient, had no dynamics and no bass whatsoever. It could not play rock or orchestral music due to its limitations. Voices sounded great. It will give it that.
cd318,

Your post could be in the Textbook of Audiophilia. Chapter "Give me a break". On the other hand, or maybe ear, if everybody agreed with it what other useless thing would we fight about?


Your lower hearing around 14 000 Hz and apparent normal above it is actually quite common and, if I remember it correctly through this fog of years, frequently observed on neural curves. Even if my life now depended on it, I could not remember the name for that. It does have something to do with the perception and some overlapping regions, but I am not brave enough to try to make it up now. It was a long time ago. Even without explanation, I hope it helps a tiny little bit.

Hearing ability changes over time and not everyone hears music the same.  If you take on of those detailed hearing examinations in an enclosed soundproof room you will see that your hearing has gaps.

it is scary.  This is a good reason why equalizers are needed.  not only for room correction, but more importantly, for personal hearing.

The problem comes when the equalizer is installed and set up for your hearing preferences or gaps and someone else comes over and listens and to them it doesn't sound quite right.

I'm pretty sure that I don't hear the highs quite as well as I once did.  My Krell KBX crossover has adjustments for that.  But, not quite as good as a decent equalizer.

I remember ages ago when I was interested in a pair of Martin Logan Sequel II speakers, I set up an appointment at Christopher Hansen in LA .  Naturally they had to set up the system so I and my friend waited in another room.  Well, that room had top of the line Goldmund Apologue (I believe) speakers, Mark Levinson 23.5 amps, Goldmund top turntable, etc.  I brought my own music and just had to hear this system.  Well the salesperson told me that it would ruin my ear for the speakers I wanted to demo.  I didn't care,

This was the first time I heard the artist step out of the speakers.  I closed my eyes and could see where artist was on the stage, the piano, the bass player, etc.  It was amazing. 

it didn't ruin my ear at all. In fact it actually helped me obtain a reference point for what reproduced music should sound like.  That was my first venture from mid fi to real high end and I've not looked back.

Glubson:  I saw the Mercedes S560 at the LA auto show.  What a car!!!  Definitely not a Versa.

enjoy

Neverthelesss, somehow we muddle on. 😛 Just wait until you hear that Raidho System calvinj was raving about.
Geoffkait I kind of notice that you always bash the systems of the guys with well means. Quit hating. I wouldn’t spend the money that guy spent on his system but the music bought him peace and joy knowing that death was coming fast. He was an experienced high end dealer who had the means and experience to put a great system together and he did it. He put the right things together in the right enviorment with equipment based on his experience that worked well together. Look if you can  put a cheap system together that makes you happy then enjoy it. But don’t always crap on people that can afford more or spend more or want to spend more by always calling them fools. If they can put a system together at costs they can afford that allows them to enjoy the music more then great for them. I’ve tried a lot of stuff and heard a lot of stuff. The more stuff the better the opinion to me. There are just some systems in the high end that if put together right can reset your ears! If you haven’t listened then watch how you comment. Cost doesnt always equal better performance. But if you put a cheap system properly matched and an expensive system properly matched the more expensive one will sound better but how much you are willing to spend will determine if it’s worth it to you!