I took a thirty year hiatus from Vinyl, so I can somewhat relate to your journey Knollbrent... at retirement an audiophile/ fellow music lover gave me a Denon TT and I have since perhaps gone down a similar path...
Since your initial post parameters seem to have evolved a bit, so shall my compliance....
My $.02 is the snarky wisdom present in this thread is a hidden gem, your mileage will of course vary....
Recent stuff ( not in any preference order )
1.) Eva Nightbird- 4 LP/Blix/UK
2.) Peter Gabriel-US / pglpr7
3.) Jacintha - Fire and Rain / 45 rpm grv 1099
4.) cowboy junkies -all that reckoning /latexlp55
5.) Michel Legrand - Legrand Jazz/imp6028
6.) Dead Can Dance - Within the Realm of a Dying Sun/cad3629
7.) London Grammer - If you wait/Columbia
8.) Joe Jackson - Night and Day/ Intervention IR003
9.) Marianne Thorsen - Mozart Trondheim Solstene/2L038LP
10.) Chet Baker Quartet- Barclay 84017
And because every amp goes to 11!
11.) Grant Green - Matador /Blue Note MMBST 84442
Recent Bin scrounging scores.... I assume you have a high end record cleaning system to suit your collection???
A mix of very recent and / or epic scores, in no order...all under $10
Mostly M-
1.) Ronald Thompson & Emma Lou Diemer - Trumpet and Organ music of the baroque/ WLA-WS-13
Echoing Eric comment + anything Water Lilly
2.) JJ Cale - FIVE /MCA SR-3163 just $1 at Goodwill
3.) Jerry Garcia - Garcia / Warner BS 2582
4.) David Lindley & El Rayo-X - Win This Record/asylum 60178
5.) David Lindley - Mr. Dave /WEA 252-161-1
6.) Valerie Carter ( RIP ) - Wild Child / Columbia JC 35084
7.) Marianne Faithfull - Dangerous Acquaintances/ Island 204-015-320
8.) Charlie Byrd - DD / Crystal clear records ccs8002
9.) Pink Martini - Hang On Little Tomato ( always a live show favorite-band ) Heinz Records HNZ002
10.) Al Di Meola - Elegant Gypsy / Columbia 34461
And for Spinal Tap
11.)) Christine McVie / Warner $2.99 in some Long Beach record dive.....