@elizabeth , all good comments.
The info on the website states that the shields are a film that adheres to the CD label, no adhesives. It’s as thin as plastic wrap for food.
I tried Herbies CD mat and it got stuck inside my CDP, so I’m very cautious about what slides into the tray/transport. In any event, I’d like to try the LAST CD cleaner instead of my homemade concoction.
Also to your point, I’m leery of possibly ruining the label on a valuable early release CD.
Good to hear that you’ve never had any peeling of the label, that is reassuring.
And I have many CDs with the silver mould center, the first generation had them. BYW, on the first release collectors market they fetch a higher price. The only ones that won’t track have pitting (like corrosion) on the center area that is raised on the surface. Maybe it affects laser reflections? Or maybe they interfere with the clamping of the disc in the transport. I realise now the tracking errors have nothing to do with the pinholes.
And as stated in the Hoffman thread, only certain pressing plants like PDO had the pinhole problem.
I have quite a few early PDO CDs, and I’ve also noticed all my discs with pinholes come from Germany.
I respect your views and experience in this hobby, so thanks.