2. digital
  3. 146766-11545

Does this exist? Preamp/Streamer/DAC with MQA, Roon and more

I'm looking for a particular set of features that seem to be very hard to find in a stereo (2.1) product. My budget is preferably around $2,500 but there is some flexibility. Here's what I would like:

Must have
-Preamp
-Network streamer
-DAC
-Roon endpoint
-MQA compatible (not interested in your opinion of MQA)

Want to have
-HDMI inputs/output for video switching only and 2 channel audio (to allow TV sound through stereo)
-Room correction
-Subwoofer management

I recently purchased the newly released NAD C658 which, when adding the optional HDMI module, covers every must have and want to have (Dirac room correction is coming in a later FW update) for a total of $1,800. Perfect! The problem is that so far the thing sounds lousy. I'm trying to let it burn in more and see if Dirac comes and makes it better, but it's not looking good after the first few days. The DAC seems to be the problem. It seems to suffer from audible time smearing and sounds too clinical and harsh so I am suspect about Dirac helping with that.

I've also seen the SimAudio Moon 390 but it's $5,300 and doesn't have room correction or subwoofer management. On the less expensive end, SimAudio also has the Moon Ace for $2,900 which has the same features as the 390, minus the HDMI inputs. I'd use the preouts to my own amp since the Ace is an integrated amp.

Then there is the Aurender A10. It costs even more than the Moon 390 and doesn't have HDMI inputs.

Cambridge Audio has some well regarded streamers but they aren't Roon compatible.

Finally, there is the PS Audio DirectStream and DirectStream Junior. I recently purchased the DSJr since it can be had close to my budget and while it sounds incredible as a streamer and DAC, it's not viable as a preamp. I spoke to PS Audio about this and they recommend using a separate preamp for the DS and especially for the Jr. I can't remember exactly why but they told me the signal to noise ratio when used straight into an amp wasn't ideal. I tested this myself and found that the DSJr sounded better even running through a Marantz AV receiver as preamp than it did straight into my amp (the receiver uses pre-outs to the same amp). I don't want to run a DSJr through a Marantz receiver and if I blow the budget on the DAC, I won't be able to get a capable preamp worthy of mating with it. Plus I'm really trying to get down to fewer boxes.

Are there any other options out there that I'm missing?
jnehma1
mbolek
176 posts
 
Jon,

Interesting thread.   I'll need to look at Audirvana.   Thanks Edsky.

I'll be trying both the DSJ and a NAD M12.   I also have the 7703 and plan on replacing it with the T758v3 for the HT room.  Auditioned the C658 and didn't feel it was that much better than the 2i.   Maybe I should have kept it longer and given it a better assessment.   Goal is to try and simplify as much as possible, but I'm steadily moving up the DAC $$$ food chain looking for the right product.

I'm now listening to the M10.   Love the build and ease of use.  Unfortunately, not using the nCore amp as I have a pair Emotiva Stealth 8s that I'm using in my stereo room.  If you remember my post over at AVSforum, my kids are older and I now have more time to listen.   Love all the new options with streaming, MQA and miss how good 2 channel audio can be..
jnehma1 OP
111 posts
 
@edsky Thanks for the feedback. Unless I am missing something though, there's no difference between what you described with Audirvana and what I can do today with Roon. In either case, the software does the first unfold but since my receiver is not MQA compatible, it wouldn't be able to do the final decode.

@mbolek Anxious to hear your feedback regarding the M10 and the T758. I don't know anything about the Emotiva speakers but assuming by your response that they are active. Do you have any passive speakers to test?
mbolek
176 posts
 
Yes.   Emotivas are active.   I have Monitor Audio SoundFrame in-walls in the HT room.

They are nice but may not be a fair speaker to test with the M10 or any of these higher $$ DACs.   May be able to get my hands on some KEF R3s.   That would be a better comparison.   
edsky
15 posts
 
@jnehma1 quite right, you can do the same with Roon. My apologies as I forgot you had Roon, as you were describing AirPlay as the mechanism you used to stream to your Marantz. I hear very good things about Roon. Though very pricey, I may give it a try someday.

If I may ask, how do you have your components set up? Are you using your AV processor and NAD pre amp to the same amplifier and speaker, or do you have two completely different setups? If using the same amplifier and speakers then I assume you run the Marantz AV pre outs into the analogue inputs of the NAD and run that in home theatre bypass mode?

Reason why I am so curious is I am exploring options around the exact same thing. If interested, here is the thread... https://www.stereo.net.au/forums/topic/262491-mqa-dac-preamplifier-with-ht-bypass/
jnehma1 OP
111 posts
 
@edsky Initially I had the Marantz receiver in the family room due to the need for dual purpose with tv viewing. I run the preouts to my Musical Fidelity amp, so the receiver just acts as a preamp and DAC. I purchased the NAD to replace the receiver as a better preamp and DAC, plus give me direct Roon streaming rather than Airplay. I don’t plan to setup an HT bypass since the family room is just a 2.1 setup. I have a separate media room with surround sound.
More to discover