The OP has a belt drive turntable with a cast aluminum platter. The turntable’s prior owner(s) probably bent the platter by pushing it down one one side. These platters aren’t designed to withstand that kind of abuse. Given what it is, the OP could try to “correct” the bend in the platter by rotating it to the high point and gently pressing down until it turns without significant runout. Bottom like is these things are a dime a dozen, easily damaged by carelessness, and the p-mount cartridges tend to be lacklustre. With that said, a well cared for turntable similar to the OP’s turntable can produce much better sound quality than its value would suggest.