@bignamehere and @ahofer:
As I've said before, don't try to carry the analogies too far. Try to get the point rather than picking an analogy apart. And for the record those analogies were meant to be over-the-top for the sake of vinny.
Yes, if you drive your Porsche on a racetrack then you are likely a sports car aficionado. (I'm a track instructor.) But as you say, no you are not a race car driver.
But if you just happen to like Porsches and sports cars but don't own one and have never driven one then you are neither an aficionado or a race car driver.
I truly don't understand why people are struggling with this. I guess part of it is that they are getting hung up on this patently stupid definition:
“An audiophile is a person who is enthusiastic about high-fidelity sound reproduction.”
Just put it into application. Someone tells you they have a low paying job, struggle to make ends meet but are very enthusiastic high fidelity sound reproduction but have never had or heard any high end reproduction but are quite sure their new bluetooth Walmart headphones are just as good.
Is this person an audiophile? They meet the definition. Right?
Time for a better definition. Maybe one where "enthusiasm" (how do you measure that?) is the prime criteria.
As I've said before, don't try to carry the analogies too far. Try to get the point rather than picking an analogy apart. And for the record those analogies were meant to be over-the-top for the sake of vinny.
Yes, if you drive your Porsche on a racetrack then you are likely a sports car aficionado. (I'm a track instructor.) But as you say, no you are not a race car driver.
But if you just happen to like Porsches and sports cars but don't own one and have never driven one then you are neither an aficionado or a race car driver.
I truly don't understand why people are struggling with this. I guess part of it is that they are getting hung up on this patently stupid definition:
“An audiophile is a person who is enthusiastic about high-fidelity sound reproduction.”
Just put it into application. Someone tells you they have a low paying job, struggle to make ends meet but are very enthusiastic high fidelity sound reproduction but have never had or heard any high end reproduction but are quite sure their new bluetooth Walmart headphones are just as good.
Is this person an audiophile? They meet the definition. Right?
Time for a better definition. Maybe one where "enthusiasm" (how do you measure that?) is the prime criteria.