Cartridge recommendation?

Grado Prestige Black from Needle Doctor. Under $100. I am a long-time Grado fan!

You could try gently used and get a lot more for your $$

Audio-Technica VM540ML is listed at $249 on Audio-Technica’s web site. Under $200 at $169 is the AT-VM95ML which probably more than 68% of what the VM540ML is. I can tell you the VM540ML is worth much more than what it sells for. 

Thanks for the suggestions! I was originally looking to get a used Denon DL-110, but I think I would need to purchase a heavier counterweight for the tonearm to use it. Any idea how these cartridges compare sonically to the DL-110? I forgot to mention earlier that I will mainly be listening to classical symphonic music.

The DL110 is a fine cartridge and will suit the type of music. Use it on the MM input.