One of the definitions of insanity is doing the same thing over and over while expecting different results. I'll give you an example of how I did this for years.
Since I already had the best jazz artists in my collection, I began to look for new artists and new music; rarely was I successful. This became a habit; a bad habit I might add, plus, at that time you had to buy the record before you listened to it. To make a long story short, I've got a lot of records that need to go to "Goodwill".
Now that I can listen before I buy, and the names of the best jazz artists doesn't change overnight, I intend to have a 99% success rate.
I have no idea why some like this and others like that, but as Rhett Butler said to Scarlett O' Hara, "Frankly My Dear, I Don't Give a Damn". Now I go for the best (as evaluated by yours truly) and leave the rest.
It helps a lot to have other like minded people who have gone through the process of selecting what they consider the best jazz available; that enables me to add "winners" to my collection faster than I can scrape up the cash.
What's music to one person is noise to another person; that's just a fact of life.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lHnjxPZGEmM
Let us scrutinize that record;
Donald Byrd – trumpet
Julian Priester – trombone
Frank Foster – tenor and soprano saxophone
Jerry Dodgion (#1, 3) – flute
Lew Tabackin (#2, 4) – flute
Duke Pearson – electric piano
Jimmy Ponder – guitar
Roland Wilson – bass guitar
Joe Chambers (#2, 4), Leo Morris (#1, 3) – drums
Nat Bettis – percussion
John H. Robinson Jr. – percussion
Here again we have "Duke Pearson", plus other "A" rated musicians. I only want records that will stand repeated listens.