wilsom MAXX3 or Evolution Acoustics MMThree ?

Janeb: Please re-read my post. I think you missed my question. It was:

"With all due respect, how can you know Ed's room is "waaay too small?" He never even posted his dimensions."

Your response was:
"I think you will find that the effect of trying to reproduce low end notes in a small space is to fall off the propagation of the wave of the note."

You keep talking about small spaces, which his is not. If I am misunderstanding you, please let me know.

Hi guys this thread seems to be a debate about Eddies set-up etc. but if you re-read the opening thread by Papaya who already owns MAXX2's and looking for advise, I don't read anywhere mentioned of any issues etc.

Papaya if you refer to my threads that's my best advise for you.

Everyone is going to have an opinion and in the end that's really all it is their opinion which is fine, enjoy which ever journey it may be you choose as I do with my MBL 101E's.

Hello Mike,

How much are the tickets to get in ? -) Beautiful room and setup..

Nice touch ...

regards,

Weseixas,

thanks. my wife thinks i should charge. :^)

seriously; if you are ever in the Seattle area you are welcome to come by for a listen.

my brand of Scotch is Lagavulin.

Jtinn, I agree that i have not seen Ed's room dimensions. However, with the pictures of his room and the relationship of the MM's to the side walls, It seems highly probable that this room is sub-par, size wise, for a speaker like the Maxx's. Sure, the Maxx's may work in some areas very well in a room like this, BUT Ed says he wasn't able to get the bass response he was looking for.. which as I said doesn't surprise me. I don't think that you could argue that the Maxx's are a bass deficient design!
IMHO, it is a given that in order to hear true bass extension you need a truly large room.( and of course a speaker than can deliver the goods). My point about the wave length of a 20hz note is well known. Shoehorning in a speaker that is too large for a given room is a very common occurrence in our hobby-- Many dealers try to upsell a larger speaker, either with little regard for the room that it is going to be used in, or what the listener is trying to accomplish, again IMHO.
Mike, the fact that the Maxx 3 is a rear ported speaker may have in fact assisted the speaker, given that the front wave has to overcome the stuffed couch which it is being asked to fire into..:0)