speaker impeadance question


Hi everyone, 

Out of curiosity I was playing around with the 4 and 8 ohm taps on my Mcintosh MC601 mono blocks last night. I currently use Sonus Faber Olympica iii speakers which have a nominal impedance of 4 ohms. I have run them on 4 ohm from day one (non bi-wired), but I was quite surprised to hear that there is a very distinct difference in SQ (positive) moving from the 4 ohm taps to the 8 ohm. So after doing a little digging I was able to find the impedance plot for the speaker and according to the plot I can see why they are rated at 4 ohm but what I don't understand is why they sound so much better at 8 ohm. What I am concerned about is the huge spike at 3khz ..see link below:

https://www.soundstagenetwork.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1285:nrc-meas...

So I thought I would throw this out on the forum to see what you guys think in regards to using the 8 ohm taps based on this plot. 

Thanks in advance

-Keith
barnettk
Lots of excellent and informative responses above, except that I believe some of them have been made without the realization that the OP’s monoblock amps are solid state. And the multiple output taps are created via autoformers, the result being that the taps have higher damping factors and lower output impedances than pretty much all tube amps.

Specifically, the MC601 has a specified damping factor of "greater than 40," which if accurate would at least in theory mean an output impedance from the 8 ohm tap of <0.2 ohms, and <0.1 ohms from the 4 ohm tap, and <0.05 ohms from the 2 ohm tap. All of those numbers will result in the amp essentially behaving as a voltage source with this and most other speakers.

So I would expect in this case that interactions between amplifier output impedance and variations of speaker impedance over the frequency range are very minimal contributors to the sonic differences the OP hears in going from one tap to another. The major contributors would seem likely to involve how the sonics of the amp itself (and perhaps also the amp’s maximum power capability) are affected by differences in loading of its output stage that depend on which tap is selected.

Regards,
-- Al

P.S: Bruce (Bifwynne), great to see you posting again!


@almarg wrote: " I believe some of them have been made without the realization that the OP’s monoblock amps are solid state." 

Oops. 

As Roseanna Roseannadanna would say: "Well... nevermind." 

Duke
Hi Duke,

I'm afraid I must offer another correction, this being a matter of considerable significance :-)

It was actually a different character, "Emily Litella," who concluded her commentary on Saturday Night Live with the words "never mind."  As I'm sure you realize, Emily Litella and Roseanne Rosannadanna were both characters portrayed by the amazingly talented Gilda Radner, who very sadly is no longer with us.

Best,
-- Al
    
"I’m afraid I must offer another correction, this being a matter of considerable significance... It was actually a different character, "Emily Litella," who concluded her commentary on Saturday Night Live with the words "never mind." " 

Well, it just goes to show you. It’s always something.

:-)

Best,
-- Al

(For others who may not be aware, Duke's statement just above was made famous by "Roseanne Rosannadanna")