Bought a pair of Magnepan LRS. Should I buy a Schiit Vidar or Bryston 3B-ST?

Whoops messed up the link while editing, here it is: https://imgur.com/a/i8c4gLf


Hello areasonableman,

     I must be missing something in your linked photos because I can't identify anything that appears cracked.  Can you please be more specific in your description of the part that is cracked?  Just for your reference, the silver/gray section in the middle of your 1st photo is a small aluminum heat sink for dissipating excess heat from the amp and, thereby, cooling it.  But I don't see any cracks on the heat sink.  Can you describe the crack in relation to its direction from the heatsink?  Such as just in front or just in back of the silver/gray heatsink, etc.?
     Also, how did you discover that UPS damaged something?

Thanks,
 Tim
   

@noble100 in front of the heatsinks, between the 4 small bronze capacitors there are what I can best describe as as small silver wheels with one continuous wire wrapped around them. I was suspicious when I first picked up the amp and heard something moving around in it, but I figured it was slightly old and may be fine.

Hello areasonableman,

     Those two 'wheels' are small toroidal transformers, which are part of the amp's power supply.  If one of those was not functioning properly on most class D amps, I believe the amp's internal monitoring circuits would cause it to shut itself down and flash some sort of default warning light.  If the amp is functioning normally, everything should be fine.
     But if you want to make certain, I'd recommend emailing your question to Class D Audio in California and ask.  The owner and amp designer, Tom Roth, usually responds himself and fairly quickly.  He's a very nice guy, very knowledgeable and helpful. Here's the link:

https://classdaudio.com/contact/

Tim


 
     

Usually with Magnepan, the more power the better, but current is less critical than most so less beefy high power amps may work quite well.

I had a Carver m4.0t amp (tube amp like SS design), 360w/ch into 8 ohm, not much more into 4, that matched with my Magnepans better than most. Not so much with other more power and current hungry speakers, much as would be expected with most higher output impedance tube amps.

The Bryston is a good amp and more then twice as powerful I believe.....I would choose the Bryston.

Hello areasonableman,

     I agree a Bryston would be a good option.  Based on my knowledge and experience,  The Class D Audio 470 will be about equally as powerful as the Brystons but will be more detailed, have better perceived bass response although a bit exaggerated due to a higher damping factor, have lower measured distortion levels, have a noticeably lower background noise level, better dynamics and will have a more neutral overall presentation.  However, the Brystons by comparison will impart a 'warm flavoring' to everything played through it that many seem to enjoy.  In other words, the 470 will be more accurate and the quality of the recording will not be masked in any way.  If you're listening to a bad recording, it will not be as obvious when amplified by the Brystons.  If possible, I suggest you listen to both to determine which overall presentation you prefer.
     If you prefer the warmer less accurate overall presentation, this can also be achieved with the choice of preamp you pair with the 470 amp. In general, tube preamps will impart varying degrees of warmth depending on the brand, model and exact tubes utilized;  solid state preamps will generally impart less warmth and are more accurate, although there are exceptions to this general guideline with both preamp designs.

Tim