Go Active Crossover or Upgrade existing XOs?



It was recently suggested to me that rather than doing a crossover upgrade 

I look into an active crossover for my Tannoy FSMs. Anyone experienced enough 

to guide me? What advantages does active provide?


gadios

An active crossover is implemented before the power amplifier so you need to have an amplifier for each driver. For this reason it is also referred to as Bi-Amping, Tri-Amping etc.

A speaker with a passive crossover can present a complex and difficult load to the amplifier, taking into account the impedances of the drivers along with the inductance and capacitance in the crossover network. In most cases active will be a significant improvement. There's a good article here that describes in much more detail.

Another advantage of active is that you don't need the enormous (and expensive) components required for passive. I'd suggest seeing if someone has already designed an active crossover for your speakers.

Just to be clear I'm talking about active analogue crossovers (using op-amps), not DSP based.


That’s the technical version. While technically correct, there must be something else going on, or all the world’s best cost no object million dollar systems would be doing this, and all the statement speakers would be designed for it. Which, wait, what’s this? None are? NONE?!?!?!

Right. And if its none of the cost no object stuff then it can’t be they aren’t doing it because it costs too much. At a certain level the more it costs the greater the bragging rights for being able to make and sell and own. And for damn sure active costs more to implement than passive. So it can only be that active crossovers in spite of the wonderful sounding technical explanation are actually worse than passive.

Reason number 812 on the list of why not to trust technical specs and reasons.
The issue with active crossovers is that they are not simple. You have to do everything the passive crossover does.

DSP is pretty much the only way to go IMHO when going active, but how much are you willing to measure, tweak and adjust?

Upgrading passive components is relatively simpler and harder to mess up, except when replacing electolytics.

Just pick the set of challenges you want. :)