Preamp Output Capacitor: Mundorf Supreme vs. Supreme Silver Oil


Anyone compared the bass response of these two caps?  I bought the Supremes for trial purposes and really loved what they did to my system's imaging (front to back layering) and immediately bought the Silver Gold Oil Supremes.  Unfortunately while they were smoother, more beautiful, and even better at imaging, they had no bass (actually, they lost bass as they broke in).  Anyone know how the Silver Oil's fit into the line?  

I'm using them in a Don Sach's DS2 Preamp ( https://systems.audiogon.com/systems/7983).  

Thanks.
128x128cal3713
@billwojo Polypropylene caps do have a type of coloration that you may not notice until you "roll" other capacitor types into your equipment. The most natural sounding caps (IMHO) are caps that incorporate wax and/or oil. 

Insulation for bare wire can be purchased as Teflon or cotton tubing. I've used both and I agree that cotton does sound more natural only when I use it in moderation. There was a point that I used cotton tubing exclusively but music started sounding brittle after using too much. Now I alternate between both materials when I mod. 

@kalali I unplug the component before I work on it. That saves my life every time :p

@cal3713 I may revisit the Mundorf S/G/O for the tweeter network. Your assessment of it's imaging seems to match Tony Gee's. It may provide depth but is the stage wide or narrow as if you're looking down a pipe or tunnel? I really dislike imaging that crams everything in the middle. 
I'm glad to see that I'm not the only ODAM user here. I think that cap is special and posted my review here
I tried a dozen different polypropylene capacitors.
All of them have "plastic" coloration. 
In term of tone, smoothness and musicality paper is oil capacitors always bit polypropylene  capacitors.
I never tried Teflon capacitors.  Teflon isolated wire sound good but less natural compared cotton isolated wires.

Regards,
Alex.
I never tried Teflon capacitors. Teflon isolated wire sound good but less natural compared cotton isolated wires.
Teflon *insulated* wire has to be either silver or silver plated. Its more likely that the wire is the problem rather than the insulation.
@c_avila1 I just opened this thread to ask people ( @grannyring ) about the front-to-back layering performance of the odams and then read your review...

"My system was already very dimensional but now it's like wearing 3D goggles for my ears."

I think you sold me. As I mentioned above, I love the tonality of my duelund's, but am missing a bit of the 3d nature of the mundorfs. I want it all.