LP made from a digital master recording...

   So much science in this discussion. Groove geometry, master recording, streaming capability, and a host of others. LP quality and digital quality will always come back to the original recording. CD's, streaming, and LP's all will suffer or benefit from that.
    If a person has a sizeable collection of LP's then it makes sense to obtain the best possible sound from them. Analog will beat out digital and digital will beat out analog depending on the source equipment, and room employed.
   With LP's there are always things to keep in mind. Care, cleaning, and, of course, equipment used. This is still, yet, another debate which has no end. Both formats have their advantages. So many variables to consider.

One thing for sure--there is rarely a digital reproduction of a pre-mid 80s analog recording that is arguably better than the original vinyl lp absent extraordinary efforts (e.g. Abbey Road, White Album)

Remember the late '70's and the Telarc digital recordings?  Vinyl records mastered from 50K digital tapes.  The audiophile magazines were unanimously griping about the sterility, lack of detail and digital glare even back then.  Admittedly, things have gotten better since then, but I still think that buying a record that was mastered from a digital source is highway robbery.  Don't get me wrong, I enjoy both digital and vinyl, my gripe is the misrepresentation of the product. 

Some of us own and push the envelope with both analog and digital formats and by both I mean vinyl, tape and high end digital.
there are hardcore in every corner, but some of us can occupy all three corners and understand relative strengths and weaknesses ego and cognitive dissonance free. Those who dismiss a format out of hand are ignorant, deaf or worse... just blowhard big ego getting in the way of a lot more accessible world class music.
iF you have an excellent DAC, night I suggest some 2L ( the Nordic sound ) downloads and the corresponding vinyl album from them. Make up your own mind , blowhard free

2L
grammy winners
find me a blowhard on this thread with chops to match 2L and the steak dinner is on me....