@spirit... To answer your question I think it really lies down to style, and of course I forgot Bonzo. Geez, I play in a freakin’ Zepp tribute. How could I forget him? To your question, yes and no. Bands like Zepp, Rush, Tool, etc really are what they are/were because of the musicians as a singular unit. When those musicians get away from that type of super group, it is fairly rare they shine quite as bright. There are exceptions. Zepp is a good example. Rush too. ELP, Tool etc. When looking at a studio/session musician usually they are a bit more rounded and perhaps more versatile overall. I learned this concept studying various music styles. Good musicians can pull off almost anything, but the true "specialists" make their style shine if you get my drift. I think musicality is subjective. Athletic drummers can be found through all styles. In terms of sheer "groove" not many can beat the likes of Bonham, Gadd, Rich, and Hakim. SO many as I said before.
Regarding WR I think some of their best days were with Erskine. Acuña was amazing for sure. I just liked Erskine’s approach and style a bit more.
Regarding WR I think some of their best days were with Erskine. Acuña was amazing for sure. I just liked Erskine’s approach and style a bit more.