I think what is being said here is that these two speakers are so different it’s like chocolate and vanilla, both are good flavors.
its really a matter of personal preference as to which you prefer.
do you really need a bunch of opinions other than your own?
Okay some people like both (flavors / sounds) and switch speakers and components in and out from time to time just to switch things up. Variety is the spice of life.
Have fun and go listen for yourself and report back your findings I bet you would have a good discussion then,.